who's our best goalkeeper

[Dithering Dougie]

Good defence.

Neither of our current keepers are up to it though.

But ones got to be better than the other, so which one is it?

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

But ones got to be better than the other, so which one is it?

I stated my preference in my earlier post. But it's like choosing between standing on a slug or a plug with no shoes or socks on.

 

[Dithering Dougie]

I stated my preference in my earlier post. But it's like choosing between standing on a slug or a plug with no shoes or socks on.

Oh yeah you're a Robles fella thanks for the honesty.

 

[Joey66]

Oh yeah you're a Robles fella thanks for the honesty.

Doug is this you starting the thread?lol

 

[JimmyJeffers]

I stated my preference in my earlier post. But it's like choosing between standing on a slug or a plug with no shoes or socks on.

I take the plug

 

[Dithering Dougie]

Doug is this you starting the thread?lol

I'm simply trying to gauge people's honest opinions Joe.

@Walsall Blue asked for a poll about our best goalkeeper and then refused to vote in it for some strange reason, but others like @butters and yourself have been confident enough to nail their colours to the mast and say Robles is our best keeper.

I admire people who back up their beliefs like that then the fence sitters who stick up pictures of Jags or say neither to be honest mate, at least it shows character.

 

[Joey66]

I'm simply trying to gauge people's honest opinions Joe.

@Walsall Blue asked for a poll about our best goalkeeper and then refused to vote in it for some strange reason, but others like @butters and yourself have been confident enough to nail their colours to the mast and say Robles is our best keeper.

I admire people who back up their beliefs like that then the fence sitters who stick up pictures of Jags or say neither to be honest mate, at least it shows character.

Doug we need a new Keeper - end off! Its whether we have the funds in January - we also need a player to complement RB in midfield, and another back up striker, where does it end?
You were always going to get the funnies on here with your stance on an over the hill Keeper!
He may be the best we have, but we will never know no pressure for his position if Butland was here he would be on the bench!
As he seems immune from being dropped!

 

[ilikecheese]

If Joel were the better keeper he'd be playing. No way does a manager who bought a player not put him in the side if he thinks it's the better option.

Not saying we don't need to strengthen the position, but the facts are the facts. I suspect the majority of the people who voted for Robles were voicing their 'anybody but Howard' opinion.

 

[ijjysmith]

If Joel were the better keeper he'd be playing. No way does a manager who bought a player not put him in the side if he thinks it's the better option.

Not saying we don't need to strengthen the position, but the facts are the facts. I suspect the majority of the people who voted for Robles were voicing their 'anybody but Howard' opinion.

I've not voted mate.

 

[Tigger]

I stated my preference in my earlier post. But it's like choosing between standing on a slug or a plug with no shoes or socks on.

Poll?

 

[Dithering Dougie]

If Joel were the better keeper he'd be playing. No way does a manager who bought a player not put him in the side if he thinks it's the better option.

Not saying we don't need to strengthen the position, but the facts are the facts. I suspect the majority of the people who voted for Robles were voicing their 'anybody but Howard' opinion.

The thing is Howard regularly get called 'the worst keeper in the league' or words to that effect, so j thought it would relevant to who people believe is the best keeper st Everton.

A lot of posters have skirted round it by saying they're both bad or posting jpegs of Jags etc which is dissapointing to be honest, I thought that's showed a lack of understanding of the club to be honest.

 

[evertony]

Let's not get personal Tony, there really is no need for it. if you want part take in the thread just answer the simple question I've asked in a fair way please.

OK...as long as you're being totally honest Douglas

 

[Dithering Dougie]

OK...as long as you're being totally honest Douglas

It's an A or B question Tony, Yes or No, 50/50. Who's better in your opinion, Howard or Robles. It's not a trick.

 

[Chang Elephant]

The 54% preferring Robles, is in reality a Howard is crap vote

 

[evertony]

It's an A or B question Tony, Yes or No, 50/50. Who's better in your opinion, Howard or Robles. It's not a trick.

Yes Douglas, it is. Some people are voting and some people are not. Everyone is being questioned on their vote. Just let them vote or not vote and let's see the results.....it's a football forum not the General Election. You are Dithering Douglas, not Jeremy Paxman. You don't need to analyse, question and cajole everyone. It's simple....let them vote or note vote.

Irony is a beautiful thing.