Nymzee
Player Valuation: £150m
Probs because he's one of our highest earners? His apps vs what we spend on him is not worth it. Whilst he's our best CB he's still not all that great it's just a low bar to beat.
- Status
Probs because he's one of our highest earners? His apps vs what we spend on him is not worth it. Whilst he's our best CB he's still not all that great it's just a low bar to beat.
He’s already played 9 league games, last season he played 29 and 24 before that.
Not sure why people are acting like he hardly plays.
We can't factor in the effect his stop/start playing has on the rest of the defence. Especially as he is the best defender we have, then it seems reasonable to expect the manager will try to play him when he's available. So when he's in the team one week and out the next, its difficult to get any consistency or understanding going between the others. We don't have enough quality defenders to pay this lazy sod thousands of pounds a week to play half of the games and if we could sell him to some other mug to finance the purchase of someone more reliable then all the better.
His wage is not breaking the bank.
I would still sooner keep him and swap two of our other centre backs.
What a weird comment. He’s done his quad because he’s lazy ?
Are you including in those nine games the multiple times he started a match and then went off early because somebody kicked him too hard ?
MACCA75
Player Valuation: £70m
And limped off in at least 2.
And what about all the other 'injuries' he's had in his time here?
Played 29 games last season.
But yes he’s faking injuries because he can’t be bothered or something.
Weird.
Nymzee
Player Valuation: £150m
But it's wages we can invest in someone that can actually play 2 games in a row.
TBH I think after this latest injury the question of selling him in the summer is probably moot- with the wages he’s on v his injury record I’m not sure we could give him away let alone get a decent fee. I’m not sure any club would view him as worth the risk.
Most likely scenario is we try to milk what we can from him next season then he leaves at the end of his contract.
Most likely scenario is we try to milk what we can from him next season then he leaves at the end of his contract.
Centre half is about partnerships and we can't build one while he cant' stay fit. We aren't even getting 20 games off him. The injuries are getting worse, not better, and that is unlikely to change over time.
He's coming into the last year of a contract and is a very high earner. Keeping him makes no logical sense. Why would we let him go for free when we can get some sort of fee.
Tuesday was the point where we should draw a line and move on from him.
Yes but this isn’t football manager where you just sell players and guaranteed replace them with somebody better who’ll play 38 games a season.
He played 29 games last season, he’s not Gbamin. You need a good centre half on the bench as well as starting so replacing Holgate or Keane would make a lot more sense.
How much do you think Mina is on ?
3 times he's gone off I believe. He's not magically going to become a player who is fit every week. We need to move on from him, and probably should already have.
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
