Was he? Or is this current knowledge applied to past events? He'd been between average and crap for 2 years and was benched for a reason, bought as a CM, played as a CM, had a great engine, poor technical skills, benched.
Compared to him, Garner is the football DaVinci - it's not about some unreal talent, it's about knowing how/when to pass, which he doesn't for most the time mate, is all.
Sadly we can't bring anyone and we're more or less stuck with him anyway, so this is a kind of pointless discussion lol