I’m down playing a club legend and his name is Kevin Campbell lol.
Let’s be serious is he really a club legend, like you say had a great start with his 9 in 8, even though we weren’t in dire straits like you make out.
We won 4 of his 8 games. Against 5 teams also struggling in the bottom half . And we only needed to win 2 of the 8 and we would have been safe.
His next 5 seasons on huge money, he averaged playing about 27 games a season scoring 1 in 3.5. Is that really value for money? And the last couple of seasons, all I remember was him being injured, which is no really surprise, this happens to a lot of players who are 34/35. That’s why the 5 yr deal was a joke.
He maybe a legend for some things off the pitch, in terms of helping the profile of the club and racism. But he definitely isn’t as a player.
Graham Stuart isn’t a Everton legend in my eyes, but he’s a bigger one than Campbell. Stuart actually scored in a pressure relegation game. And had a huge impact in the cup win.