There’s something about this season that no team seems to be as good at home. No way Liverpool lose 6 in a row at home, no way City lose to ten men Leeds at home, no way we lose so many normally if fans are there.
That said though it’s been the same for every team so for those criticising the home form they should also be praising the second best away record in the league.
This is the thing though mate, unfortunately we can't use that argument because then - as you say - it would have impacted our away form.
The away results have been great. As Carlo himself said, more about spirit than quality. But there's likely no way we win 11 away games playing the way we have done in them if fans were in the ground. Not because we've played poorly, but because it's all backs to the wall stuff and if those home teams had a bit more impetus from the fans/pressure on refs etc, it could be different.
Whereas, honestly, I can't actually think of one home game that we've lost since the turn of the year where we can reasonably put it down to a lack of fans from a performance perspective.
For example, if we had played the system we did v Burnley at home and there'd been 40,000 fans in, we'd still have been ripped to shreds through the middle because there was a huge gap. Similarly against Fulham, if we'd have played with the five slow central mids in the Xmas tree, we'd still have been passed around whether fans were in there or not.
Maybe we might have rescued a draw in some matches, but that's why I think the argument about fans is a difficult one to make, because as you say it's the same for every team. And I think in these specific home games - Fulham, Burnley, Villa - our downfall has been as much on the tactics, system, lack of attacking identity, as it was on the players.