2019/20 Djibril Sidibe

[Goat]

Personally wouldn't buy him but it just shows you how poor Coleman has been, Simple crosses or forward passes is all we need.
Would stick with JJK depending on how he develops and sign another one, Would release Coleman, He's done in the Premiership tbh.

Why wouldnt you sign him?

Does mans think World Cup winning Right backs grow on trees?

We got lucky with Coleman and we got lucky with Digne after having Baines for so long, but need I remind you of the Hibbert and Oviedo era?

Kenny had a few weeks were he shone, but since then hes been a bit poo, no idea if hes gonna come back or even if hes good enough at all.

As for Coleman hes 31 now, I personally dont think hes done, not sure why everybody is claiming as such, but we probably need an upgrade.

 

[Goat]

I mean as far as JJK is concerned whoscored ranks him as the 23rd best RB in the German league.



It ranks Sid as the 10th best RB in the Prem.

 

[evertonarntwe]

He isn't the standard he is.

"Stinking the place out though"... Really? Nonsense.

The last game he played he was absolutely abysmal, it was embarrassing

He's been awful for years. Fact

 

[Lelouch]

Why wouldnt you sign him?

Does mans think World Cup winning Right backs grow on trees?

We got lucky with Coleman and we got lucky with Digne after having Baines for so long, but need I remind you of the Hibbert and Oviedo era?

Kenny had a few weeks were he shone, but since then hes been a bit poo, no idea if hes gonna come back or even if hes good enough at all.

As for Coleman hes 31 now, I personally dont think hes done, not sure why everybody is claiming as such, but we probably need an upgrade.

I have no problem with how he's performed so far but I wouldn't rush to sign him as soon as the window opens that is all, He'd be a last resort buy if they fail to find another RB.
Coleman is finished for me, Coleman is not making that cross for Richarlison against Southampton and that is the difference he doesn't do the basic things he tries to be clever and take everyone on and he's fell off big time, He'd be an okay back up like Baines who you wouldn't mind keeping but I don't want him starting every game.

 

[ForeverBlue92]

I have no problem with how he's performed so far but I wouldn't rush to sign him as soon as the window opens that is all, He'd be a last resort buy if they fail to find another RB.
Coleman is finished for me, Coleman is not making that cross for Richarlison against Southampton and that is the difference he doesn't do the basic things he tries to be clever and take everyone on and he's fell off big time, He'd be an okay back up like Baines who you wouldn't mind keeping but I don't want him starting every game.

Yep thats my thinking - Coleman is 2nd choice at best now & Sidibe hasn't exactly set the world alight. Been good going forward but quite suspect at the back.

 

[EnglishRoundabout]

Come on, he’s only played a few matches! Give him a chance. Looks very assured to me.

 

[Lanolin]

It's going very well, check out the Everton players on loan thread. The Schalke fans love him and want him to sign permanently. I think we can put to bed the "he's a championship player" rubbish. Sidibe, doing well so far, I don't want him in JJK way next season though, JJK is the future.

They may well want him to stay, but the thread suggests that in the vast majority of games he's been rated as 'OK' rather than particularly good. He's doing alright for a midtable Bundesliga team, I don't think he's put anything to bed just yet.

 

[TimHowardsBeardJuice]

Yep thats my thinking - Coleman is 2nd choice at best now & Sidibe hasn't exactly set the world alight. Been good going forward but quite suspect at the back.

Seems like his weakness is positional awareness/holding shape. He got badly caught out on the third Brighton goal, for one.

Maybe that gets better with more playing time.

 

[Saint Domingo]

Considering Coleman has been all over the show defensively anyway I think I’ll stick with the fullback who can actually cross a ball or pick a pass.

 

[Albro]

I don't actually blame Sidibe for his lack of defending, I blame Gbamin (or lack of). Same with Digne. They're hard done by given we tend to play without a recognised DM.

 

[COYBL25]

Considering Coleman has been all over the show defensively anyway I think I’ll stick with the fullback who can actually cross a ball or pick a pass.

We have a winner.

 

[Toffeelover]

I have no problem with how he's performed so far but I wouldn't rush to sign him as soon as the window opens that is all, He'd be a last resort buy if they fail to find another RB.
Coleman is finished for me, Coleman is not making that cross for Richarlison against Southampton and that is the difference he doesn't do the basic things he tries to be clever and take everyone on and he's fell off big time, He'd be an okay back up like Baines who you wouldn't mind keeping but I don't want him starting every game.

What other choices are out there for Jnauary or Summer signing that you know of?

 

[Nymzee]

I don't actually blame Sidibe for his lack of defending, I blame Gbamin (or lack of). Same with Digne. They're hard done by given we tend to play without a recognised DM.

You can’t be a full-back and just expect midfielders to do your defending for you.

 

[Lelouch]

What other choices are out there for Jnauary or Summer signing that you know of?

I don't, I wouldn't have a problem if we sign him on a perm but I wouldn't just rush into it because he did a decent job on loan.

 

[Toffeelover]

I don't, I wouldn't have a problem if we sign him on a perm but I wouldn't just rush into it because he did a decent job on loan.

Still got Cuco though, have we?