Otamendi Stones and Kompany are all better than Van Dijk. He’s a good defender yeah but really the mythology around him has been blown wildly out of proportion. ‘He’s a rolls royce’ ‘sorted the defensive problems’ ‘could play for any team in the world’. To me their form in the back half of the season looked just as defensively suspect as before. Conceding 4 at Roma, 3 to Madrid, Palace caused them all manner of problems, as did West Brom, even we had a glut of chances against them at Goodison. United beat them with ease and could have been out of sight at half time, Chelsea who weren’t even playing for their manager also could have had a few.
The times I’ve seen him he mixes some nice touches on the ball and some over the top shouting with being positionally all over the shop.
They paid a world record fee for a defender, for that you expect the world’s best, he’s nowhere near the bracket of Ramos Varane Umtiti Godin, not even close, he’s probably not even in the bracket underneath that either.