Guest viewing is currently limited
Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

  • Participation within this subforum is only available to members who have had 5+ posts approved elsewhere.

Eva Carneiro leaves Chelsea

Status
Not open for further replies.
Titus Bramble said:
This. He just needed to say "sorry, heat of the moment, the doctors were just doing their duty" yadda yadda yadda and that would have been the end of it.

Instead, here we are how ever many months later with millions of pounds at stake after someone losing their job. Mental really
Click to expand...
If you were really cynical you might say he did in on purpose in order the get himself sacked and be available for the utd job. He's single-minded enough to do such a thing.
 
LinekersLegs said:
Settlement agreed before Carneiro took the stand...full public apology bynthe club but not by Mourinho.
Click to expand...


They really need to look at their lawyers though - going into a court case saying that they had offered her loads of money and her job back is not the best way to go about claiming they were innocent of what was being alleged. Having a go at her for being a self-publicist and leaking to the media is superbly hypocritical as well.

edit: also thats a great non-apology from Mourinho at the end there
 
zirc said:
If you were really cynical you might say he did in on purpose in order the get himself sacked and be available for the utd job. He's single-minded enough to do such a thing.
Click to expand...
Wouldn't put it past him. The most self serving man in footy. Great manager, don't get me wrong, but he's one obnoxious get
 
tsubaki said:
They really need to look at their lawyers though - going into a court case saying that they had offered her loads of money and her job back is not the best way to go about claiming they were innocent of what was being alleged. Having a go at her for being a self-publicist and leaking to the media is superbly hypocritical as well.

edit: also thats a great non-apology from Mourinho at the end there
Click to expand...
Good chance that if Mourinho was still at the club there wouldn't have been a settlement, apologies aren't really his thing and wouldn't surprise me if he still thought he did nothing wrong.
 

She had a solid case on the course of events and premier league head injury guidelines alone, why was she trying to gain extra leverage with the gender related claims?

She was a pioneer in a male dominated industry, but IMO she's somewhat devalued her accomplishments with that rubbish.
 
Sy- said:
She had a solid case on the course of events and premier league head injury guidelines alone, why was she trying to gain extra leverage with the gender related claims?

She was a pioneer in a male dominated industry, but IMO she's somewhat devalued her accomplishments with that rubbish.
Click to expand...
Sat in court were you? Or perhaps you were a colleague at Chelsea that saw different to the behaviours she claimed she had to suffer? If not I'd pipe down, or you might look like a bit of a mysoginist.

And what are her accomplishments? Being recognised as an accomplished professional first and not as a woman? Well she had to go to court to get that recognition.
 
jal123 said:
Sat in court were you? Or perhaps you were a colleague at Chelsea that saw different to the behaviours she claimed she had to suffer? If not I'd pipe down, or you might look like a bit of a mysoginist.

And what are her accomplishments? Being recognised as an accomplished professional first and not as a woman? Well she had to go to court to get that recognition.
Click to expand...

dNVvntX.gif
 

Sy- said:
She had a solid case on the course of events and premier league head injury guidelines alone, why was she trying to gain extra leverage with the gender related claims?

She was a pioneer in a male dominated industry, but IMO she's somewhat devalued her accomplishments with that rubbish.
Click to expand...

For a start, one would imagine that the evident desperation that Chelsea displayed in settling this - openly admitting to offering one million, apparently ending up at five million - would suggest that there probably was going to be an awful lot of strong evidence demonstrating why the gender claim was put in there. The one correct statement that Chelsea put out at the start of these proceedings was that she would not get anywhere near a million for a finding of unfair dismissal, after all.

Secondly, don't forget that for at least two weeks various "stories" appeared in the Press that were aimed squarely at her, were very personal and were entirely unjustified. I would imagine that living through that, when all you have done is what you are paid to do, results in a giving-zero-fooks state when it comes to smashing the people responsible into a million little bits.
 
Adversus said:
She's 100% in the wrong. She's not a normal doctor because she's part of the team and Mourinho was right that she made a mistake in the context of the game and who are we to argue that it wasn't a mistake that she made.

He then treated her exactly the same as the male colleague and afterwards she went on social media and undermined his position.

There's definitely sexism at play here but it's the fact that deep down everyone feels sorry for Eva Carneiro, the pretty young female doctor getting a verbal assault from Jose Mourinho, the grumpy old man.

Frankly this whole case will set back equality decades because it shows in a male competitive environment hiring women is a risk.

I still hope he loses.
Click to expand...

Leading contender in the "Worst Post in GOT History" competition right there.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register
Back
Top