Everton’s worst best 11

[fitzyefc]

Unsworth and Neville make this team easily. Unsworth the only home player ive seen booed at goodison twice.

 

[Ghost Rider]

You not understood the thread have you mate?

Clearly not

 

[greener]

we must have an honourable mention for Per Koldrup!

and my all time fave, Terry Curran! Awesome loan spell then went to shiz when signed!

I saw Curran play several times here on the south coast, world class or completely abysmal, sometimes both in the same game.

 

[Bigduke1234]

Gascoigne and Ginola were world class, but I don't know why the others get a mention. Even Mark Hughes. Very good at his
best, but not really world class, imo.

Eto’o clearly fits but I am with your sentiment

 

[Papa Shango]

John Collins was pretty big at the time and I don't remember him doing much?

I always felt that people got the wrong impression of Collins.

Loads had him down as some silky smooth playmaker probably because he played abroad. He was always a bit of a "solid footballer" type player, one of those who doesn't seem to do much but all the players claim that he is boss.

He did fill in admirably at left back for a while I suppose.

 

[Papa Shango]

5 pages in and not a single James Rodriguez shout. I'm disappointed.

There is one literally in the very first post!

 

[Efcjake]

Don't think anyone has claimed this one yet.

Franny Jeffers' second spell.

 

[Kylito]

There is one literally in the very first post!

Missed it somehow. My brain has officially stopped reading James as "Hamez"

 

[Gaffa]

There’s a lot of young posters on this forum with some of the names being banded around. Unsworth in the worst eleven? John Collins? Really!!

Here’s mine since 1983 and I have been a regular every season so this took some doing and I’ll have at least 50 players on the bench

Paul Gerrard
Paul Holmes Carl Tiler Philip Senderos Earl Barrett
Mitch Ward Claus Thomsen Gareth Farrelly Andy Van Der Meyde
John Spencer Brett Angell

If anyone ever saw Claus Thomsen play

 

[chippy1722]

People who put Unsworth in their worst 11, have been privileged.
Unsworth was half decent compared to quite a few left backs we’ve had.
Can we include Martina as a right and a left back.

 

[Preki]

It's meant to be class players past their best. Not crap players who were never good!

 

[Gaffa]

It's meant to be class players past their best. Not crap players who were never good!

Oh well I’ve replied anyway. I wouldn’t get too worried about it

 

[JimmyJeffers]

Enjoying how confused this thread has made people.

 

[Gaffa]

Enjoying how confused this thread has made people.

I enjoyed narrowing down 200 crap players into 11. Took me all afternoon.

 

[Papa Shango]

I enjoyed narrowing down 200 crap players into 11. Took me all afternoon.

And you still put Carl Tiler in your team!

There was nothing wrong with Carl Tiler!

Know the most frustrating part? I can't even back up my outrage (which happens often regarding Tiler) as he was a bog average centre back in the 90's there isn't even any videos of him doing anything of note.

Earl Barrett is always a polarizing one, you either love him or hate him.