Simon Buttle
Player Valuation: £50m
Its from a Newcastle thing on twitter
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
BlueStevie35
Player Valuation: £70m
Are they legit though? Not clickbait
Is there a world where this minteh fella is just another vlasic or lookman because we ended up selling vlasic for like 14 mil and lookman for 20 mil and there’s no way this minty fella can be worth around 40 mil after just one loan spell. He isn’t even prem proven yet.
Billy Dean
Player Valuation: £70m
MACCA75
Player Valuation: £70m
windymiller
Player Valuation: £50m
I'm absolutely loving how angry all of this is making the overseas fans of the franchise clubs. I hope we do loads more of it.
nonstripdzebra
Player Valuation: £1m
If Thelwell pulls off some three card monte with DCL to Newcastle exchange for Minteh he deserves incredible props for how he's been moving in this window. Im assuming we are paying a difference in such a deal, but the question of how much is really hard to discern. If his eval is around 40 million I don't see how that's feasible unless DCL pays for half of that the other way. Then we start to enter some plausible ground. 20 million for a touted winger in exchange for an expiring contract is not ludicrous although arguable.
But removed of if our limited resources would be better served allocated elsewhere, Thelwell is proving nifty. To try to cook a trade for a player we would be loosing almost certainly in 12 months to lower the asking price of a target is savvy. And the same in the Villa deal. Not sure who initiated the Dobbin deal but I think we got the better end of that talent wise with Iroegbunam regardless of both motivated by PSR. Who knows where Iroegbunam shakes out but I was pretty sure Dobbin wasnt an EPL level talent.
But removed of if our limited resources would be better served allocated elsewhere, Thelwell is proving nifty. To try to cook a trade for a player we would be loosing almost certainly in 12 months to lower the asking price of a target is savvy. And the same in the Villa deal. Not sure who initiated the Dobbin deal but I think we got the better end of that talent wise with Iroegbunam regardless of both motivated by PSR. Who knows where Iroegbunam shakes out but I was pretty sure Dobbin wasnt an EPL level talent.
Last edited:
It’s magnificent
Tilling
Player Valuation: £6m
Can see why you think that but no, Thelwell has a long standing interest in Broja (see also N'Diaye)
The only issue is that the amortisation is recurring annually so you need to keep the trick going year on year.
“hey, barcodes. We will give you an extra 10m for Minty if you give us an extra 10m for DCL … deal ?”
We are going to be linked with everyone aren't we ?
jonnyboy316
Player Valuation: £35m
That worries me. Broja is a complete Donkey IMO
Would be immense. Sadly reality is it’ll be someone useless.