GK: Olsen
RB: Kenny / Coleman
CB: Keane / Mina
CM: Delph / Gomes / Sigurdsson / Gomes
FW: King / Bernard / Tosun / Iwobi
I would argue that James and
Sigurdsson are very likely playing for the same position and given Gylfi's game time and contribution (4 goals/4 assists) play Carlo wanting him to sign a new deal.
Coleman - also has enough to play as support to a new right back.
Gomes - so poor you named him twice, is for me very much a square peg in the team. Last night he showed good signs when he set Richarlison through before he went off injured. Again similar to Coleman, he has played ok but we could instantly buy someone who does his role far better.
Keane/Mina - I'd put Holgate over either one of these two. As a defensive two, they have been our best pairing all season and I feel Godfrey and Branthwaite would be better suited as a partner to either or.
Iwobi - Not a lot you can say apart from not the best buy Brand made. Showed glimpses this season but he has played largely left wing for Arsenal then we moved to right wing for us. Another square peg.
Bernard - Same as Iwobi, just doesn't fit the narrative under Carlo. Rumours of him leaving in January but he'll hopefully move this summer.
Olsen/King - Loans who are just not good enough.
Kenny/Tosun - Out on loan. Kenny has played all 9 games he has been available so a good from a sale point of view but Tosun is just Tosun, expect another loan we pay for.