Shall we sack him?
Im not saying you're saying that, I'm just asking, would you sack him?
No mate, as much as I'd like to sack him, Brands, Dunc, the kit man, the players and the tea lady and turn Goodison into a car park right now.
But I would be asking serious questions at how utterly inept we have consistently looked and why he keeps doing the same things that don't work.
If we'd been tosh all season, or as in like last year where it was clear how bad the team was, I'd be more lenient and say yes, it is mostly the players.
While I think the players are, on the whole, not great, we have seen them win big games this year when they've been set up right. So they're not totally useless. Neither is Carlo, but he's been utterly useless in a lot of situations where we've needed him not to be this season.
We've had three purple patches of results and the rest has been crap.
I don't see any basis of an attacking system. It's reliant on an injury-prone player and set-pieces. When we do try to attack, we can't defend. When we set out to defend, we can literally only defend and nothing else.
I'm worried because while I fully agree we need more players, it's not showing any sign that there's anything in place for those new players to come into.