Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Match Thread Everton v Aston Villa - Preview, Match Report and MotM Poll
- Thread starter blue to the bone
- Start date
- Status
Marius57
Player Valuation: £60m
It was incredibly blatant. Even a bad ref couldn’t not give it. VAR certainly would have double checked his decision.
terryefc
Player Valuation: £10m
No worries mate.
Cool_Blue
Player Valuation: £35m
If we get relegated, blaming referees is ridiculous after 38 games. They can’t all hate us.
And I’ll be amazed if we’re not down before the Bournemouth game. If we survive, Dyche will have his own statue built.
I'm not blaming Reffs as such...though they're all seriously average and that's being generous.
But when you're at the bottom the crucial decisions always seem to not go your way...but it's your own fault you're at the bottom to start with - well actually, not having a decent forward or two.
terryefc
Player Valuation: £10m
It's a horrible task to pick a MoM when we've lost and no-one has played particularly well.
I don't think McNeil was anything special but he was clearly our best player. He'd maybe get a 6/10 - whereas most of the others would be between 3-5/10.
I know we can be biased against the ref - especially when we lose - but he was really poor yesterday. I do however think it was a penalty - and that falls on Gana making such a stupid challenge in the box. We do give away a lot of stupid fouls in and around our area that inevitable lead to goals. We don't seem to have very intelligent players but at least the chief culprit - Gordon - has gone.
I'd like to see these MOM polls have a couple of options added - one should definitely be no-one as MoM, I'd also like to be able to see the name and rate the ref for the game. This fella was a joke abd would get 3/10 if I'm being generous. It would be interesting to see if there are ny trends or are we all just moaning cos we lost.
I also despise these time wasting tactics. Martinez was guilty and was booked for it - but the ref - or timekeeper - whoever is responsible - didn't really add much on than what he normally would. Nearly every time someone goes down - or as I'm seeing more and more - fakes a head injury - play is stopped. It's crazy - and just being abused - so the team who are losing will always lose out. Funny how it's never the losing team who go down with such 'injuries'. Just play on for Christs sake. If the injury is serious enough the ref should be responsible for stopping play - but let's be honest - this should be few and far between.
I don't think McNeil was anything special but he was clearly our best player. He'd maybe get a 6/10 - whereas most of the others would be between 3-5/10.
I know we can be biased against the ref - especially when we lose - but he was really poor yesterday. I do however think it was a penalty - and that falls on Gana making such a stupid challenge in the box. We do give away a lot of stupid fouls in and around our area that inevitable lead to goals. We don't seem to have very intelligent players but at least the chief culprit - Gordon - has gone.
I'd like to see these MOM polls have a couple of options added - one should definitely be no-one as MoM, I'd also like to be able to see the name and rate the ref for the game. This fella was a joke abd would get 3/10 if I'm being generous. It would be interesting to see if there are ny trends or are we all just moaning cos we lost.
I also despise these time wasting tactics. Martinez was guilty and was booked for it - but the ref - or timekeeper - whoever is responsible - didn't really add much on than what he normally would. Nearly every time someone goes down - or as I'm seeing more and more - fakes a head injury - play is stopped. It's crazy - and just being abused - so the team who are losing will always lose out. Funny how it's never the losing team who go down with such 'injuries'. Just play on for Christs sake. If the injury is serious enough the ref should be responsible for stopping play - but let's be honest - this should be few and far between.
I still can't get over ow biased Taylor was. Not even "bad", he literally was making wrong calls all the time.
also it was mcginn who had the ball in the box, not prime kane, maybe just maybe he would not have scored even if he got his shot away, similar to how maupay shot straight at their keeper in the box
Don't dive in to challenges inside the box when we have men around the ball
Another horrific mistake from Gueye who can't go 90 minutes without making a terrible mistake. What a terrible signing, based on sentiment rather than the needs of the team
Another horrific mistake from Gueye who can't go 90 minutes without making a terrible mistake. What a terrible signing, based on sentiment rather than the needs of the team
chippy1722
Player Valuation: £35m
I’ve been one of McNeills biggest critics but he pretty much done his job yesterday, got plenty of crosses in and won us a few corners. It’s not his fault we have no one in the middle.
sorry but he won the ball on the replays it shows
Maybe
It's a 50 50 call for me. Don't dive in and give a fussy referee a chance to award a penalty. A good midfielder stays on his feet in that scenario.
but he still won the ball if that isn’t given then who knows
- Status