Realistic, yes. Likely, no.
I think we've made great progress, but the wishful thinking - or dreaming - gets a little grating when trying to have a rational discussion of what we can expect to achieve this term. This matters because there are quite a few who will start pointing fingers at Carlo if their unrealistic expectations are not met. Can we win the Cup? Yes, we can - three wins are not beyond most top flight sides. Can we finish fifth? We have an outside chance of finishing fourth. Are we likely to do either? No. Are we likely to miss out on winning the Cup and fifth place? Probably. Is Dave negative? No, he's utterly realistic. Does he take relish in his realism? Absolutely. That's what makes him entertaining. Over the last 25 years, the realists were derided as "negative", yet their predictions have, almost without exception, been proven to the be accurate, reliable ones.
I suppose if you come here to dream, Dave and his ilk are party poopers. If you come for analysis, like I do, maybe it's time to accept you've come to the wrong place.