Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Goats squad analysis thread 2019/20

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think its totally unrealistic to expect the club to buy 2 Strikers in 1 window, but thats just me.

Yes 2 in 1 window might be asking a bit too much but I was thinking maybe line up someone like Mandzukic on a loan in January till the end of the season.
 
Manager: Marco Silva

GK
Jordan Pickford
Jonas Lössl
Maarten Stekelenburg

RB
Séamus Coleman
Cuco Martina

LB
Lucas Digne
Leighton Baines

CB
Yerry Mina
Michael Keane
Mason Holgate
Matthew Pennington

DM/CM/AM
Gylfi Sigurðsson
André Gomes
Fabian Delph
Tom Davies
James McCarthy
Morgan Schneiderlin
Muhamed Bešić
Beni Baningime
Callum Connolly

Widers
Richarlison
Bernard
Theo Walcott
Henry Onyekuru
Yannick Bolasie
Kevin Mirallas

ST
Dominic Calvert-Lewin
Cenk Tosun
Oumar Niasse

Total players: 29

Players culled so far: 14

A.Williams(OOC), Jagielka(OOC), JJK(Loan), Vlasic(Sale), Sandro(Loan), Galloway(Free), Virginia(Loan), Dowell(Loan), Garbutt(Loan), Tarashaji(Loan), Robinson(Sale), Lookman(Sale), Gana(Sale), J.Williams(Sale)

Players purchased so far: 3
Lossl, Gomes, Delph

Be interested to see if Gibson comes into the first team squad.
 

Be interested to see if Gibson comes into the first team squad.

It will depend on many factors :

1. Is he still here, we might possibly look at a loan if we think hes not needed just yet
2. How Silva views Holgate in terms of RB/CB and also if hes still here
3. I know people have said this Gbammin fella can play CB, im not convinced, but again, it will depend on how Silva/Brands rates him as a CB

Currently I dont see him getting many minutes, but im looking at it from a POV that we have got in a CB, plus Gbammin and we view Holgate as a viable option, this may of course change.
 
Zaha isnt a Striker.

Ive said we need a Striker AND a wing forward, attackers and Strikers difference seems to the issue here.
I know he isn't. My point is that if that cash is there and the trophy-signing is not there for us to make a reality, the cash will be switched elsewhere to beef up the attack.
 
I know he isn't. My point is that if that cash is there and the trophy-signing is not there for us to make a reality, the cash will be switched elsewhere to beef up the attack.

Trophy-signing? People do realise Zaha plays for Palace after flopping at United, the only statement his signing makes is that Brands has morphed into Steve Walsh.
 
We actually could do with two attackers coming in. Ideally we get DCL out on loan / sold, have two new strikers who can place pressure on each other for the attacking spot, and have Richarlison in hand as someone who can come in due to injury/suspensions as an emergency striker who leads the attack. Also get Zaha in and add some pace and virtuosity.

The end of last season we did very well against the odds of having a gummy attack. That should have been addressed right at the start of the window. Now we're in a mess.
Two attackers(Kean+another) would be disastrous imo. DCL is a perfect backup, young, promising with plenty of quality (bar finishing).
In addition as you say, we could use Richarlison here, so in case of Kean flopping or being injured, we have more than adequate cover.

I know opinions on DCL are split to put it mildly, but I honestly believe it is unrealistic to get in 2 strikers better than DCL in our current state.
A loan could swing both ways, but I personally love DCLs current development, and think he is a real asset. If we had more prolific wide attackers(Zaha?), it would take a lot of weight of his shoulders (Bernard and Walcott especially comes to mind), and playing second fiddle/putting pressure on Kean should be a perfect setup for him imo.
 

He's a star. Our competition to sign him are Arsenal and Napoli, not Aldershot and Notts County.

One of the rare occasions I very much agree with Dave.

But yeh, both of you and @MarcelsGoat are bang on really.

The money - seems to be - there for a big signing, as it stands. I don't just mean a big name, but a big-money addition and most likely that will be in the forward area.

I think we all need to stop viewing our attackers as strikers/wingers etc. They're all forwards it seems in Silva's eyes. The big plus of Zaha is he can play anywhere in that frontline very well. If we do go back for him and get him I'll be delighted, as I just think, realistically, he's the best player we could attract for that role right now.

But, I'd be delighted to be surprised.
 
Two attackers(Kean+another) would be disastrous imo. DCL is a perfect backup, young, promising with plenty of quality (bar finishing).
In addition as you say, we could use Richarlison here, so in case of Kean flopping or being injured, we have more than adequate cover.

I know opinions on DCL are split to put it mildly, but I honestly believe it is unrealistic to get in 2 strikers better than DCL in our current state.
A loan could swing both ways, but I personally love DCLs current development, and think he is a real asset. If we had more prolific wide attackers(Zaha?), it would take a lot of weight of his shoulders (Bernard and Walcott especially comes to mind), and playing second fiddle/putting pressure on Kean should be a perfect setup for him imo.

This is exactly the logic in going for Zaha, I believe.

We need a wide forward who can get into/close to double figures, just like Rich does and then Gylfi from midfield.

That means that if DCL can get his 7/8, and if Kean can get 9-10, it's not the end of the world. We have goals from elsewhere.

Bernard, as much as I like him, is never gonna be that goalscoring wide man imo, though reckon he's capable of 5-7 easy if he just gets a bit more composure - which will come if, like we did late last season, we regularly create two or three chances for each of our attacking players in every game.
 
This is exactly the logic in going for Zaha, I believe.

We need a wide forward who can get into/close to double figures, just like Rich does and then Gylfi from midfield.

That means that if DCL can get his 7/8, and if Kean can get 9-10, it's not the end of the world. We have goals from elsewhere.

Bernard, as much as I like him, is never gonna be that goalscoring wide man imo, though reckon he's capable of 5-7 easy if he just gets a bit more composure - which will come if, like we did late last season, we regularly create two or three chances for each of our attacking players in every game.

Stop talking about Zaha, im not allowed to lie in this thread, its my rule, I wont troll and I wont lie.................

FFS

Zaha is a very good player, he creates mayhem, he makes people foul him, in our set up, with Zaha on 1 side, Rico on the other and the boy Moist through the middle, my word, it it clicked, World Cup mate.

I love little Bernie, but his digits were quite poor, if he wants to play more, hes gonna have to up those, but hes got magic in his boots, hes the type you would pay to watch. Im hopeful he can improve next season and show his class.

Look for me we need a Wing forward, wider, attacker, whatever you wanna call him and Zaha has proven he can play in this league and to a degree stand out, he would cost a vast sum, but hes a quality player.

Now no more Zaha talk in here, its not a speculation thread!!!!!!!!

:hayee:
 
Two attackers(Kean+another) would be disastrous imo. DCL is a perfect backup, young, promising with plenty of quality (bar finishing).
In addition as you say, we could use Richarlison here, so in case of Kean flopping or being injured, we have more than adequate cover.

I know opinions on DCL are split to put it mildly, but I honestly believe it is unrealistic to get in 2 strikers better than DCL in our current state.
A loan could swing both ways, but I personally love DCLs current development, and think he is a real asset. If we had more prolific wide attackers(Zaha?), it would take a lot of weight of his shoulders (Bernard and Walcott especially comes to mind), and playing second fiddle/putting pressure on Kean should be a perfect setup for him imo.
A decisive move this summer when Kean is confirmed would be to sell DCL and have his successor lined up. That's what a club on the up would do. DCL fails at doing what he's there to do: score. Keeping him to run around is like saying you should keep a guard dog without any teeth because they can still bark.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top