Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2017/18 Gylfi Sigurdsson

Status
Not open for further replies.
Gylfi, Coleman, Walcott, Pickford and Gana.

Think we have the base of a good side there.

This for me too. We need big upgrades in the other 6 positions. I think aslong as we upgrade at minimum 4 of those positions and persist with Tosun & Keane for another season if needs be is fine.

Pickford

Coleman Keane ??? ???

Gana Siggurdsson ???

Walcott Tosun ???
 
Dolberg wasnt as succesful as DCL last season mate and in a lower standard.

Football levels havent dropped off a cliff mate. You just expect too high a standard from pkayers 21 and younger. Simple as.

DCL is among the best around in his age group. Doesnt mean he will become world class or prolific. But that doesnt change where he is right now.

I don't think I do expect to high a standard tho... lookman has things that stand out, rashford also, lukaku did , ali is only a year older. DCL doesn't have any special stand out qualities that I can see
 

Don't be so naive. I love Coleman but he's not as good post-injury and he's not as good as Sigurdsson.

This doesn't really make sense. Sigurdsson is injured and got injured just after Coleman came back so by your metrics everybody is better than Sigurdsson as he has not played...

Coleman is our most important player. Sigurdsson has talent obviously but in an Everton shirt he has shown the square root of nothing other than a couple of fancy goals so far.
 
This doesn't really make sense. Sigurdsson is injured and got injured just after Coleman came back so by your metrics everybody is better than Sigurdsson as he has not played...

Coleman is our most important player. Sigurdsson has talent obviously but in an Everton shirt he has shown the square root of nothing other than a couple of fancy goals so far.

Not even going to pretend any of that made sense.

Coleman as he is now is not as talented a footballer (A.K.A. good) as Sigurdsson is. Simple as that.
 

Not even going to pretend any of that made sense.

Coleman as he is now is not as talented a footballer (A.K.A. good) as Sigurdsson is. Simple as that.

You are saying (From what I can tell..) Coleman is not as talented as he used to be because he has missed time with injury yet Sigurdsson is injured currently yet that doesn't matter?

I am intrigued as to why you think he is a better player (and OK, its hard to compare different positions). What his Sigurdsson done in an Everton shirt to get such praise? He has been pretty average at very best so far.
 
You are saying (From what I can tell..) Coleman is not as talented as he used to be because he has missed time with injury yet Sigurdsson is injured currently yet that doesn't matter?

I am intrigued as to why you think he is a better player (and OK, its hard to compare different positions). What his Sigurdsson done in an Everton shirt to get such praise? He has been pretty average at very best so far.

No I'm saying Coleman isn't as good playing now than he was pre-injury. I haven't seen Sigurdsson post-injury to know if he's dropped off.

I just think he's more talented and adds more to the team offensively which was Coleman's biggest plus. He's obviously pretty solid defensively but that's harder to see if a crap back 4.
 
You are saying (From what I can tell..) Coleman is not as talented as he used to be because he has missed time with injury yet Sigurdsson is injured currently yet that doesn't matter?

I am intrigued as to why you think he is a better player (and OK, its hard to compare different positions). What his Sigurdsson done in an Everton shirt to get such praise? He has been pretty average at very best so far.

No I'm saying Coleman isn't as good playing now than he was pre-injury. I haven't seen Sigurdsson post-injury to know if he's dropped off.

I just think he's more talented and adds more to the team offensively which was Coleman's biggest plus. He's obviously pretty solid defensively but that's harder to see if a crap back 4.
 
I don't think I do expect to high a standard tho... lookman has things that stand out, rashford also, lukaku did , ali is only a year older. DCL doesn't have any special stand out qualities that I can see
I've never once said he's standout or compared him to Rom at the same age. All I've ever said is he is a top striker in his age group and too young to write off yet.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top