billycopper
Player Valuation: £40m
Keep the faith.
- Status
Keep the faith.
Sharpys top lip
Player Valuation: £60m
No he's a bit **** really. His lack of concentration sometimes is shocking really.
atypicalusername
Player Valuation: £35m
The lad can play and is only going to get better. Wonderkid is over the top but he is a cultured player and is only going to get better with more games. He has everything going for him in terms of height, speed and the basics. He is only 20 after all.
Without a question or a shadow of a doubt in my mind i think he will be a trully world class midfeilder.
Does he have any outstanding attributes? - What are they?
He has it all really, great techniuqe, vision, power, pace, two footed, the ability to score in the box and from deep, he is two footed, that said he does have some weaknesses that will be ironed out of his game with coaching.
Has he ever looked capable of taking control of a game or turning one on its head? - When?
You could argue his introduction against Utd at home last season, impacted us positively he was cetainly a positive influence on us, for me his best game.
Does he have a presence on the field?
Yes and no, i have seen him play amongst players his own age coming from deep with his pace and power and running at midfeilders and deenders, this is see as his great strength going on into future, given he is a scoring threat and a gifted technical player - i see him very much as an opposition half midfeilder.
Where is his natural position? Some mutter centre half? Is he box to box? Defensive midfield? Attacking midfield?
I certainly see him as a midfeilder, i think he will eventually play in a similar role to Lamaprd and Gerrard - though i think he will be better then both. Its his pace and power really coming from deep, i think is a huge danger, he has ability to hold on to the ball and make up yards - we havnt seen a lot of it at senior level but he has it. I see him presently playing in the role that Fernades used to play left or right just in front of an anchor, be it Neville, Heit, Mofro, Arteta. He will and can do damage from the centre line up.
At 20 years of age What do we have on our hands here? The next Michael Carrick or the next Steven Gerrard?
For me he will defo be on a par with Gerrard and Lamaprd, this lad has more natural talent then both IMO, which is why there is so much intrest in him over the years, the raw tools this guy has are absolutley frightening once he develops the confidence, tactical awarness and consistencey to use them, what he lacks can be coached what he pocesses is god given gifts very few footballers have had naturally, all the best coaches can see it which is why so many are sniffing around - its about spotting them - which most Everton fans seem to have missed.
Not a shadow of doubt in my mind, he will be world class, or by the time (hopefully) he leaves us will be worth 50 mill.
Does he have any outstanding attributes? - What are they?
He has it all really, great techniuqe, vision, power, pace, two footed, the ability to score in the box and from deep, he is two footed, that said he does have some weaknesses that will be ironed out of his game with coaching.
Has he ever looked capable of taking control of a game or turning one on its head? - When?
You could argue his introduction against Utd at home last season, impacted us positively he was cetainly a positive influence on us, for me his best game.
Does he have a presence on the field?
Yes and no, i have seen him play amongst players his own age coming from deep with his pace and power and running at midfeilders and deenders, this is see as his great strength going on into future, given he is a scoring threat and a gifted technical player - i see him very much as an opposition half midfeilder.
Where is his natural position? Some mutter centre half? Is he box to box? Defensive midfield? Attacking midfield?
I certainly see him as a midfeilder, i think he will eventually play in a similar role to Lamaprd and Gerrard - though i think he will be better then both. Its his pace and power really coming from deep, i think is a huge danger, he has ability to hold on to the ball and make up yards - we havnt seen a lot of it at senior level but he has it. I see him presently playing in the role that Fernades used to play left or right just in front of an anchor, be it Neville, Heit, Mofro, Arteta. He will and can do damage from the centre line up.
At 20 years of age What do we have on our hands here? The next Michael Carrick or the next Steven Gerrard?
For me he will defo be on a par with Gerrard and Lamaprd, this lad has more natural talent then both IMO, which is why there is so much intrest in him over the years, the raw tools this guy has are absolutley frightening once he develops the confidence, tactical awarness and consistencey to use them, what he lacks can be coached what he pocesses is god given gifts very few footballers have had naturally, all the best coaches can see it which is why so many are sniffing around - its about spotting them - which most Everton fans seem to have missed.
Not a shadow of doubt in my mind, he will be world class, or by the time (hopefully) he leaves us will be worth 50 mill.
He's not all that. Loads of hype as a lid but just won't develop.
We'll probably end up selling him to someone like City on reputation alone for £15m where he'll go on to be damp squid and offloaded to Sunderland for a fraction of that price in the years ahead. I know it might not be the universally held view but I like that Gibson at United. I'd rather have him.
We'll probably end up selling him to someone like City on reputation alone for £15m where he'll go on to be damp squid and offloaded to Sunderland for a fraction of that price in the years ahead. I know it might not be the universally held view but I like that Gibson at United. I'd rather have him.
Last edited:
fozzy
Player Valuation: £60m
the thing is its not what Potential we think he has! its what the board think his Potential transfer fee is!
and i gotta say if we get the right money for him (ok could do with an england cap) then i think the money could do the team more favours than he ever could!
i just dont think hes got the balls to grab a game by its short and curlys! dont get me wrong if we had the money to keep him then i would say yes keep him and hope he becomes a "great" player! but sadly we aint!
and i gotta say if we get the right money for him (ok could do with an england cap) then i think the money could do the team more favours than he ever could!
i just dont think hes got the balls to grab a game by its short and curlys! dont get me wrong if we had the money to keep him then i would say yes keep him and hope he becomes a "great" player! but sadly we aint!
CahillsCornerFlag
Player Valuation: £70m
Could Jack Rodwell be world class? He certainly could. Will he be? I'm not so sure. It's all mental whether or not he makes it for me, the ability is there, he just need that quiet confidence that all world class players have in their own ability.
Personally, getting £20m+ for him would be great dealing, as he could well turn out to be average.
Besides, I'm more excited by this Barkley lad.
Personally, getting £20m+ for him would be great dealing, as he could well turn out to be average.
Besides, I'm more excited by this Barkley lad.
little curly alan ball
Player Valuation: £70m
To use an Analogy ; L.C.A.B. ; Booker Prize Winner ...???
See , IT COULD HAPPEN ,....
Ive backed this Kid from the off , but in truth he singularly failed to " Grab " any game this Season , esp' when Injury's REALLY HIT ...
I could be wrong ... It dont happen often , but it can occur , so we shall see , I suppose ...
There is a lot in the mental side of things, part of it confidence, part of it tactical awarness and reading the game, some of it is developing consistentcey and impacting on 90 mins of a game, players with a fraction of the talent he has have mastered it, i gaurentee you one day he will do something and convince himself he is the best player on the pitch and he will be - watch him go from there.
Lets be honest, two years ago people were calling Mofro a striker.
Lets be honest, two years ago people were calling Mofro a striker.
thebluefox
Player Valuation: £50m
bally ive told ye mate moyes doesnt fancy him. he would sell him tomorrow .i dont think young jack would come back to hurt us
Muggins
Player Valuation: £60m
D
Deleted member 28206
Guest
I know lcab, and foxy respectively have direct output/input from Goodison, but ive heard this as well, Moyes doesn't" fancy the kids". I heard it direct from one of our youth/reserve/ now shipped out Mark Hughes gob.
I should hope not, this isn't South East Asia lad ffs.
billycopper
Player Valuation: £40m
He fancies Kylie!
Matt Damon
Player Valuation: £60m
Moyes "didn't fancy" Seamus Coleman according to some not so long ago.
What happened there then?
Maybe it should be "not quite so in-the-know" when it comes to (some who claim to know) Moyes and his thinking ey?
What happened there then?
Maybe it should be "not quite so in-the-know" when it comes to (some who claim to know) Moyes and his thinking ey?
Last edited:
- Status