Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Confirmed Signing Jake O'Brien

Status
Not open for further replies.
My biggest gripe with this signing is it shows how piss poor our scouting is. Lad went for peanuts last Summer which means we’re basically just signing him on last season’s showing and nothing beforehand.
You think Palace would have sold him to us for 1m when their part owner Textor has multiclub things with Lyon?
 
He went for under 1 mill didn’t he? If we fancied him then, we’d have gone for him. We’re still far too reactionary.

Or maybe we didn't buy a guy who'd never played higher than the second tier Belgium league, but now he's played a full season in a good league we have done because he's shown he's good enough. How much has that full season in France improved him as well. If we'd bought the player that Lyon did, last season he'd have literally sat in the u21s all season wouldn't he?
 

Or maybe we didn't buy a guy who'd never played higher than the second tier Belgium league, but now he's played a full season in a good league we have done because he's shown he's good enough. How much has that full season in France improved him as well. If we'd bought the player that Lyon did, last season he'd have literally sat in the u21s all season wouldn't he?

Well nah he’d have been loaned out or in the seniors given his age and experience. But you basically agreed with my point that we’re signing him on the back of 9 months of play.
 
He went for under 1 mill didn’t he? If we fancied him then, we’d have gone for him. We’re still far too reactionary.
Yeah he went for a mill and in general I massively agree with your point that our scouts are crap and recruitment is too reactionary. Minteh probably an even worse example of that.
But a big song and dance was made of how the only money out last summer was for Danjumas loan fee so we might have literally not even been able to afford a mill. Then on top of that we breached PSR whilst having to sell off the entire academy including Samuels Smith so even if we wanted to it wouldve been a tough sell.

But im going to not give them too much benefit of the doubt because there's absolutely no way anyone at the club was aware of him anyway even if we could afford him. It is worth noting though if we did sign him last summer that he wouldn't have kicked on at all because he'd have sat on the bench for the whole season.
 
He went for under 1 mill didn’t he? If we fancied him then, we’d have gone for him. We’re still far too reactionary.

Mate it's insane logic, why didn't united buy Braithwaithe last year from us, why didn't villa buy Onana when he was 17, hell Lindstrom we should have gotten from Brondby fir a few million too tbh.

Can say that about literally any transfer ever.
 
Mate it's insane logic, why didn't united buy Braithwaithe last year from us, why didn't villa buy Onana when he was 17, hell Lindstrom we should have gotten from Brondby fir a few million too tbh.

Can say that about literally any transfer ever.

I mean no, you can’t.

We literally did the correct thing signing Branthwaite from Carlisle didn’t we. Or Dom from Sheff Utd.
 
Well nah he’d have been loaned out or in the seniors given his age and experience. But you basically agreed with my point that we’re signing him on the back of 9 months of play.

Ofc we are, the same way we now value Jarrod at north of 70m based on
.... 9 months of play.
 

I mean no, you can’t.

We literally did the correct thing signing Branthwaite from Carlisle didn’t we. Or Dom from Sheff Utd.

Long term ofc we did, but neither of them walked into the team, Jarrod and DCL both took a few years to start to feature.

But unless you wanna turn into Zatara mate with a squad of prepubescents then you can't always sign the player 'before' they've actually shown they can handle that step up.

Take our business this season - Tim could very well turn into one of those players, but premier to premier there's a huge premium, if you think palace would sell him to us for 1m you're living in cuckoo land, they gave a massive fid punt and btw have a big sell on fee because they are in essence a sister club almost.
 
I mean no, you can’t.

We literally did the correct thing signing Branthwaite from Carlisle didn’t we. Or Dom from Sheff Utd.

Can also throw about thirty bsnes of similar types of purchases that people won't even remember where ever at the club mate.

Buying 1m players is an absolute gamble and the vast majority don't work out
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top