James McCarthy

[Tree13]

100% at fault for Witsel's goal. Hopefully it's a metaphor for Witsel coming to Everton and taking his place in the squad.

EDIT: he's immediately hauled off LOL

 

[fareastblue]

I did not really know what he did for the past 60 min

 

[GrandOldTeam]

Took a lot of stick when I said Martinez needed to go, and McCarthy should be first out the door after him.

Still maintain it. McCarthy is a limited footballer. He wouldnt get in the starting 11 of any team who finished top 10 last season...

 

[argietoffee]

Huge achievementto make Glenn Whelan look the better of your two central midfielders

 

[Username]

Turd since he stopped tackling everything!

 

[sageyefc]

Crap

 

[jcgefc]

I am definitely guilty of looking back to his first season with us in the hope he can be that player again.

The sad fact is though that it was a complete one off, he just isn't good enough.

Think we should be replacing him this summer.

 

[Neiziro]

Was a mainstay in the Wigan team that got relegated.

Get rid.

 

[Goat]

Should have taken the 20m when offered.

Cant see Koeman giving him a chance playing like currently does.

 

[cronullasharks]

Didn't even know he was on the field

 

[Stephenlloyd]

Took a lot of stick when I said Martinez needed to go, and McCarthy should be first out the door after him.

Still maintain it. McCarthy is a limited footballer. He wouldnt get in the starting 11 of any team who finished top 10 last season...

Said the same for a while now. Amazingly some on here still won't him in the team @BlueToff
Obviously happy with mediocrity

Fortunately we have a manager who wants the best

 

[tommye]

He's surrounded by bang average championship players against some of the best midfielders in the world.

But Ireland being crap is his fault.

#EvertonianLogic

 

[ianefc]

Took a lot of stick when I said Martinez needed to go, and McCarthy should be first out the door after him.

Still maintain it. McCarthy is a limited footballer. He wouldnt get in the starting 11 of any team who finished top 10 last season...

True. Im wondering if injuries have affected him mentally? He ran his socks off In his first year and was everywhere, start of 14/15 season picked up a few injuries and has never been the same player.

 

[ianefc]

He's surrounded by bang average championship players against some of the best midfielders in the world.

But Ireland being crap is his fault.

#EvertonianLogic

He's been woeful for us too. Barry looked about 4 leagues above him last season.

 

[Tree13]

He's surrounded by bang average championship players against some of the best midfielders in the world.

But Ireland being crap is his fault.

#EvertonianLogic

Bang average championship players like Whelan and Hendrick have looked comfortably better than him mate. They do basic things like running and tackling.