Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2023/24 Kevin Thelwell

Status
Not open for further replies.
Interesting that he's been very proactive in the market now the certain master transfers negotiator is out the picture.

Almost like he being allowed to do his job.
Likewise, Brands got pelted by the fans for some of our transfer dealings, but he rightly called out that there were too many parties involved.

With no Kenwright and Moshiri, hopefully we can start to get some form of real strategy in place, so we can utilise what precious resources we have.
 
Likewise, Brands got pelted by the fans for some of our transfer dealings, but he rightly called out that there were too many parties involved.

With no Kenwright and Moshiri, hopefully we can start to get some form of real strategy in place, so we can utilise what precious resources we have.
Well we certainly wouldn't have had Maupay up top of those 2 crabs weren't interfering.
 

he's had his hands tied severely since he joined, and most our transfers have been sell to buy and/or buy now paying in 10 years stuff

regardless though, singning beto for 20m+ is a massive concern, he must have watched him a good few times and decided we should sign him, he's not a footballer him
 
Who was behind Maupay? Genuine question.
I have no idea, but I would expect it to be Lampard and Thelwell.

Easy to be critical in hindsight, but I still to this day think the Maupay signing made some sense.

Everton did not have much money available and needed a striker. Lampard was somewhat flexible with formations and with Maupay, they had a striker that could play together with DCL.

Financially having like for like alternatives that does not play together is extremely expensive. If one plays well, the other one ends up getting benched and can't retain his market value. Most clubs can't afford to have two good and similar strikers fighting for one position.

We tried that when getting in Beto. Even when DCL had a poor season, Beto suffered from lack of minutes and poor performances. What did we pay for Beto? 25 million? I can't see any club willing to pay 15 for him now. He's turning into Cenk.

The main problem with signing Maupay as a striker that could play both alone as a 9 and with DCL, was that DCL got injured. And it got even worse by Everton replacing Lampard with Dyche. It will always be impossible for a Maupay to shine playing Dyche-ball.

Maupay was poor for Everton, but that doesn't make him a poor footballer. He did OK for Brentford last season. Looked better than Beto ever will. And if you ask 100 top managers if they want Maupay or Beto in their squad, I am sure the majority would pick Maupay.
 
I have no idea, but I would expect it to be Lampard and Thelwell.

Easy to be critical in hindsight, but I still to this day think the Maupay signing made some sense.

Everton did not have much money available and needed a striker. Lampard was somewhat flexible with formations and with Maupay, they had a striker that could play together with DCL.

Financially having like for like alternatives that does not play together is extremely expensive. If one plays well, the other one ends up getting benched and can't retain his market value. Most clubs can't afford to have two good and similar strikers fighting for one position.

We tried that when getting in Beto. Even when DCL had a poor season, Beto suffered from lack of minutes and poor performances. What did we pay for Beto? 25 million? I can't see any club willing to pay 15 for him now. He's turning into Cenk.

The main problem with signing Maupay as a striker that could play both alone as a 9 and with DCL, was that DCL got injured. And it got even worse by Everton replacing Lampard with Dyche. It will always be impossible for a Maupay to shine playing Dyche-ball.

Maupay was poor for Everton, but that doesn't make him a poor footballer. He did OK for Brentford last season. Looked better than Beto ever will. And if you ask 100 top managers if they want Maupay or Beto in their squad, I am sure the majority would pick Maupay.

So Lampard?
 

I have no idea, but I would expect it to be Lampard and Thelwell.

Easy to be critical in hindsight, but I still to this day think the Maupay signing made some sense.

Everton did not have much money available and needed a striker. Lampard was somewhat flexible with formations and with Maupay, they had a striker that could play together with DCL.

Financially having like for like alternatives that does not play together is extremely expensive. If one plays well, the other one ends up getting benched and can't retain his market value. Most clubs can't afford to have two good and similar strikers fighting for one position.

We tried that when getting in Beto. Even when DCL had a poor season, Beto suffered from lack of minutes and poor performances. What did we pay for Beto? 25 million? I can't see any club willing to pay 15 for him now. He's turning into Cenk.

The main problem with signing Maupay as a striker that could play both alone as a 9 and with DCL, was that DCL got injured. And it got even worse by Everton replacing Lampard with Dyche. It will always be impossible for a Maupay to shine playing Dyche-ball.

Maupay was poor for Everton, but that doesn't make him a poor footballer. He did OK for Brentford last season. Looked better than Beto ever will. And if you ask 100 top managers if they want Maupay or Beto in their squad, I am sure the majority would pick Maupay.
It definitely made sense at the time. He had 10, 8 and 8 the previous 3 seasons in the prem. Not prolific but as a back up striker he seemed an ok buy. He just proved to be absolutely shocking when playing for us. I remember him getting into some decent positions but his reactions/shooting was just awful.
 
Come on mate, nobody really knows what hes cooking.

I mean we have 2 right backs with a combined age of 73, let him cook.
Yeah but the comment I replied to said if he makes a particular signing we owe him an apology, it would take a few successful signings before he should be taking any credit. I agree with the right back thing considering we tried to replace Coleman with Sidibe and Martina god knows how long ago. DOF just doesn’t seem to work at our club.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top