uglykidjoe1982
Player Valuation: £750k
Oi, Thelwell, bring us your timesheet, there
ElGato
Player Valuation: £10m
True, but I've been saying for some time that our squad is better than last year's aberration and that we need to match or improve on our league position from last year (11th) with a better style of play. It was on Dyche to demonstrate that he could adapt to those players and realise that, and he couldn't
Players of the profile of Godfrey, Onana, Gomes, Alli, Holdgate, all assembled under different managers with different playing styles, all rid of for Lindstrom, Mangala, JOB, Ndiyae, Tim, more technical ball players. And he made us £35m in the summer
Again: I think he's doing a good job.under the circumstances. Slowly shipping out the dead wood whilst building a squad of young players with a more clear common identity behind them. I'm certain that it has been Dyche that has held that identity back, but that's my opinion. Hopefully Moyes brings that out a bit more
Still work to do though, I agree. And some of the players that have been signed aren't up to it. Broja was a baffling one, but maybe worth a punt. Beto is odd but maybe that's got more Dyche to it than Thelwell
EFC_FRANCIS
Player Valuation: £35m
It doesn't make sense either way to me.
Either TFG are happy with him but for some reason haven't offered a deal yet.
Or they aren't happy with him, and so likely do not rate him but are trusting him with making a lot of decisions with multi-millions of pounds at stake with impacts on future years.
It's similar to when Mosh was unhappy with Brands and couldn't decide whether to renew him until 2 weeks before it expired.
I personally think they've kept him to show Moyes round any new rooms at FF and to see if he wanted his office decorating.
If they were really impressed with his work I'd have imagined he would have been offered a deal instantly. Maybe he doesn't want a deal, maybe he thinks he's done the best he can and wants a change.
It'll be interesting to see how it pans out.
pfim
Player Valuation: £40m
They haven’t hired a CEO. They really wanted to stick with Dyche but he opted out. I don’t think they’re looking to change things for a bit, and aren’t in the mind to start handing out contract extensions to people they don’t know.
bluestevon
Player Valuation: £80m
I think they are evaluating him mate.
They'll give him money in January, but it don't be the TFG groups 'big' splurge, that'll come this summer to the tune of 100m plus - like they did at Roma.
January they maybe give him 30-35m plus any sales (Beto, Keane?)
End of season he'll be reviewed based on his how his years signings perform.
The correct way to judge him tbh
Whether you think he’s done a good or bad job up to now or even in between.
It’s a simple equation for me:
He is out on contract in the summer of 2025.
Is he the best DOF Everton can get?
It’s that simple.
It’s a simple equation for me:
He is out on contract in the summer of 2025.
Is he the best DOF Everton can get?
It’s that simple.
I'd like to think they'll evaluate everyone but anyone worth their salt would be going to their employer and say "listen, I've busted my balls in tough times and now your here and you've got a bit of clout, give me the tools and I'll take us to the next level".
I don't get that sense at all that this fella is going to be the man for the job. We'll see though, I like 3 signings he got for the u18s last summer and that makes me think he might have people in place to help him.
Based on that question I'd say no.
I've got my mum ahead of him, about 7 posters on here who pick out players who end up being boss at other clubs, and I'd back my kettle to do a similar job
Just my opinion though.
Does your kettle have 120 point plan though!
It got to point 6 and laminated itself to death
stamullenblue
Player Valuation: £25m
Tough job over the Moshiri era .. big window for him here and maybe better time to judge when over .
I think as Dyche proved, you can be the right man and achieve good outcomes in a limited context.
When that context changes though can others do it better?
Part of me would be loyal and say he deserves a shot, but another part of me thinks sentimentality is something that hast helped us in the past.
So I end up at…his contract in up…..so is he the best possible DOF we can get?..it’s an opportunity to make sure we get the absolute best we can.
Nothing personal just business,
stamullenblue
Player Valuation: £25m
As i said. Big window for him
beto was purely a panic buy to get a striker in
i had my doubts about it from the beginning
Confirmed Signing Post in thread 'Beto'
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
