New user so I will give my take.
The blame game has begun. There's no doubt we are poorer now than when we ended last season and bringing Sigurdsson in isn't going to change that. The loss of Lukaku is huge. When Liverpool lost their star striker they went from almost winning the league to 7th. Frankly if we finish in the top half we will be doing well and I think next season rests on having an easy run in the Europa league and fluking champions league that way.
Now that doesn't absolve Moshiri or Koeman. While it's true it's increasingly looking likely Koeman has been sold a lie like the rest of us. It's also true the money hasn't been spent well or at least in the right positions.
We have no half decent fullbacks and our CB pairing is dreadfully slow which is the reason our defense has been so deep all the pre-season games. This along with the fact we have no pace to hit teams on the break means the opposition can just camp in our half applying a high press whenever they lose the ball. Against teams like Spurs and Liverpool we could get absolutely hammered. Giroud isn't going to fix that because even if he can hold it up we don't have the players that can get up to support him.
Bringing back Rooney wasn't a good call. Martina isn't good enough. We didn't need Schneiderlin because we already had Besic, Gueye, Davies etc Klassen is incredibly slow and will only work with fast play makers around him - he's the guy who finishes off chances coming from deep not a play maker, in this current team he does and will look awful but I think it's just that he doesn't suit us. With Lukaku, Barkley and Deulofeu he would have worked well. Sigurdsson is a very good player but lacks pace and again won't fit. Bolasie was a waste. Pickford looks great but we are going to lose Robles for nothing because we bought him. Is he really 30m better than Robles?
These are the "Koeman" signings I just don't see the logic in them.
However I think Walsh has done an ok job with the cheaper signings like Lookman and Gueye etc. Not sure about a few like DCL but at those prices we will always have more misses than hits.
If Moshiri is serious in investing in the team and that's a big if there's a good chance the reason why there's a holdup is because he doesn't want to spend close to 80m on two players either over 30 or close to it when so far the signs are far from good. Koeman on the other hand is basically saying he hasn't his team yet and those two signings will turn it around and make the entire thing click. Would you gamble 80m on that?
However there's also a very strong possibility Moshiri is a bit of a fraud too.
Right now we just don't know but the ball is firmly in Moshiri's court.
The blame game has begun. There's no doubt we are poorer now than when we ended last season and bringing Sigurdsson in isn't going to change that. The loss of Lukaku is huge. When Liverpool lost their star striker they went from almost winning the league to 7th. Frankly if we finish in the top half we will be doing well and I think next season rests on having an easy run in the Europa league and fluking champions league that way.
Now that doesn't absolve Moshiri or Koeman. While it's true it's increasingly looking likely Koeman has been sold a lie like the rest of us. It's also true the money hasn't been spent well or at least in the right positions.
We have no half decent fullbacks and our CB pairing is dreadfully slow which is the reason our defense has been so deep all the pre-season games. This along with the fact we have no pace to hit teams on the break means the opposition can just camp in our half applying a high press whenever they lose the ball. Against teams like Spurs and Liverpool we could get absolutely hammered. Giroud isn't going to fix that because even if he can hold it up we don't have the players that can get up to support him.
Bringing back Rooney wasn't a good call. Martina isn't good enough. We didn't need Schneiderlin because we already had Besic, Gueye, Davies etc Klassen is incredibly slow and will only work with fast play makers around him - he's the guy who finishes off chances coming from deep not a play maker, in this current team he does and will look awful but I think it's just that he doesn't suit us. With Lukaku, Barkley and Deulofeu he would have worked well. Sigurdsson is a very good player but lacks pace and again won't fit. Bolasie was a waste. Pickford looks great but we are going to lose Robles for nothing because we bought him. Is he really 30m better than Robles?
These are the "Koeman" signings I just don't see the logic in them.
However I think Walsh has done an ok job with the cheaper signings like Lookman and Gueye etc. Not sure about a few like DCL but at those prices we will always have more misses than hits.
If Moshiri is serious in investing in the team and that's a big if there's a good chance the reason why there's a holdup is because he doesn't want to spend close to 80m on two players either over 30 or close to it when so far the signs are far from good. Koeman on the other hand is basically saying he hasn't his team yet and those two signings will turn it around and make the entire thing click. Would you gamble 80m on that?
However there's also a very strong possibility Moshiri is a bit of a fraud too.
Right now we just don't know but the ball is firmly in Moshiri's court.