It's not that people are saying he's perfect, they're remarking that he's the best striker we have had for a long while and certainly the one who will get even better, and mostly that it's very harsh and peculiar to see the amount of criticism he gets from our own.
I like Lukaku and was glad we signed him, and you're right, he is the best striker we've had for a long time (since Yakubu).
But it's very close to verging into "At least he's not Brett Angell" territory. I'll admit that most of the complaints i have about him i make such an issue out of them because people seem to ignore them and simply mention his age and make excuses for him.
The whole "as long as he scores goals nothing else matters" stuff, which Greame Jones himself has disproved recently.
Even good strikers have bad seasons, Rooney is one of the few who despite being played out of position or injured has always managed to deliver even at a young age but that is what makes him superb.
Agree with you that there are parts of Roms game that need to be developed, not sure that there are too many people that disagree tbh. He was poor at times last season but he was also great at times, it is not unusual for any striker to be erratic let alone a young one.
You just seem to expect him to be this fully developed and consistent machine because we paid 28m and it doesn't work that way. Soldado cost that much and can only dream of having as bad a season as Rom
I don't expect him to be fully developed and perfect. But he's got worse instead of being better every season like people claimed he would.
Taking everything into account, the fact he is the most expensive player in our history, the fact he has played over 200 compettive first team games at a high level, the fact he has had top level coaching from the Belgium national team, Chelsea and Everton yet still has trouble controlling a ball and bringing his team mates into play when asked to do so.
Which admittedly, is just as much Martinez's fault for trying to make him play a way he isn't suited rather than using him in a way to get the best out of him.
But i'd like to think that considering how good people talk about he is (you know, more goals by 21 than Messi and gonan be the best striker in the world) he'd be able to do the basics better than he can at this stage of his career.
And if we are gonna keep using him the way we do, and he is gonna play how he did last season, we might as well flog him for a profit and get a striker who out performed him last season but will play the lone striker role better and more suited to how we play as a team, thus making us better as a team.