2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

[marcus]

We need to stop the kneejerk reactions. It would be all too easy to sack Silva and bring in a caretaker manager. Then in the summer bring in someone else but what happens when they inevitably have a bad run. Do we get shut and continue to tailspin. The sad reality is that we should finish between 7th and 12th and not win a cup.

The top 6 have far more money than us. Far better squads and have had years to build their Clubs up. We stagnated under Bill and are playing catch up. The only way we will catch those ahead if us is to have stability and to be smarter than the clubs above us. That is not as exciting as the rush that sacking a manager and hoping for a miracle brings but it is far more pragmatic and realistic.

Brands and Silva have only been here 5 minutes and we shouldn't expect miracles. Give them the rest of this season and then next season and then see where we are.

Hardly knee jerk when we have been watching inadequate defending all year...

Seen nothing yet to convince me Silva can make any progress...

But I am prepared to give him more time...

But come on zonal marking,set pieces, the same formation no change...

 

[davek]

Cannot blame the defence purely on Pickford.

That’s mental.

Starts from him. He is the major issue in that defence.

 

[Ring master]

Defo has not been with the players then,20-30 hours lol

 

[Efcgaz83]

No mark manager of a no mark club.

Who just knocked a team valued at 300m out the fa cup

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

David Moyes is a class above any of the clowns we’ve had managing us since. Reckon he’d have put up with the likes of Schneiderlin Mirallas and Williams being on the pisstake all last season.

Yeah - I reckon some of the players would be getting plastered to the wall if he was here at the moment.

 

[Saint Domingo]

Defo has not been with the players then,20-30 hours lol

If that’s true then the players either won’t ply for him or he’s a poor coach.

 

[DanEFC92]

Starts from him. He is the major issue in that defence.

 

[blulouie]

"And now the end is near
And so I face the final curtain"

"I did it my way"

I used to think this with Martinez .

Nothing has changed.

 

[BlueStevie35]

FYI all those advocating Pellegrini, his West Ham team are currently 2-0 down to bottom of League One Wimbledon

 

[Fansince1988]

Cannot blame the defence purely on Pickford.

That’s mental.

Our defence and keeper are very good players, but as a group under silva are totally useless. A defence minded manager would sort that out in a week. I believe we acaully have the personal sorted for our defence but unfourtuatly no one within the club can coach them to play as a unit.

 

[The Missing Lineker]

Have previously advocated sticking with him but finding it difficult to defend him now. Found him intolerably irritating standing on the sides with his hands behind his back and just looking so lost. Desperately uninspiring.

 

[blulouie]

If that’s true then the players either won’t ply for him or he’s a poor coach.

Or the tactic doesnt work....like all season.

 

[sheedys left foot]

For there 2nd and3rd goals millwall had players on our six yard box and there wasn't an Everton player within 2/3yards of them that is schoolboy defending at its worst but the most worring thing of all is that it's not the first time this season silva cannot keep making the same mistake again and again.That defending was spineless and clueless am going to bed the gang of shithouses

Ironically zonal marking would have worked here as we would have won the second ball. Instead 3 of our back 4 had a brain fart and all went for the same ball

 

[catcherintherye]

David Moyes is a class above any of the clowns we’ve had managing us since. Reckon he’d have put up with the likes of Schneiderlin Mirallas and Williams being on the pisstake all last season.

Can you see a situation where Moyes might come back?

 

[Cork Evertonian]

It's a very worrying situation right now.This club is an absolute shambles.I really hope Silva turns it around.But i do get the impression, that the job is too big for him.We are floundering, and he has to show now, that he can turn it around.If this rot continues on for the rest of the season, then Silvas days here are numbered.