Have you all read this. From The Times.
At long last….a National journalist who says it as it is:
Super League rebels got off lightly — why are Everton being crushed?
new
Martin Samuel
Saturday October 28 2023, 6.00pm
When six clubs conspired towards the ruination of English football for their selfish ends, the Premier League knew exactly what to do. It fined the European Super League rebels £22 million, collectively. So, roughly £3.66 million each for a plot that would have destroyed our domestic game. That showed them.
Yet if Everton are proved to have contravened profit and sustainability rules, the same body is pushing for a 12-point deduction. So, pretty much, relegation. In the past two seasons, with a 12-point deduction, Everton would have gone down, as they would on five other occasions this century. With seven points from nine games in this campaign, Everton would almost certainly drop if docked the Premier League’s recommended 12 points.
It used to be the EFL that sought to kill clubs for financial misconduct, but now the Premier League has developed a taste for blood. The desire to crush Everton is no doubt related to the looming government regulator and wanting to show politicians that the league can be trusted with self-regulation. Yet whose fault is it that football is now coming under the remit of Westminster? It would be those six clubs again, who combined in a betrayal so heinous it suggested football required external control, handing the game to the politicians.
Yet they got away with it. Compared with Everton, if the Premier League has its way, at least. There was no relegation for Manchester United, Arsenal, Liverpool, Tottenham Hotspur, Chelsea and Manchester City. There should have been, if we’re talking justice.
The rightful punishment for attempting to break away from the league should have been to get their wish. Except, instead of moving into a closed-shop Super League with Real Madrid and Barcelona, they should have been allowed to enter the Championship and see how the other half lived. Six up, six down, and we’ve got six right here, handily. Norwich City, Watford, Brentford, Swansea City, Barnsley and Bournemouth would have been the beneficiaries, presuming no play-offs, and then the “big six” could have fought it out for promotion like weasels in a sack. Three up the first year, and three waiting it out until the next, providing they all delivered. The second tranche would have got back at the end of last season. Now that’s a deterrent.
It was never going to happen, of course. The Premier League were too worried about driving them into the greedy arms of the European elite to make an example, and too worried about the harm to their own product. Yet who would have benefited had the Super League six been significantly punished? A club such as Everton, perhaps, or Wolverhampton Wanderers, Brighton & Hove Albion, Crystal Palace, West Ham United, Leicester City. A club straining every sinew, spending every penny, just to keep up — at the risk of a 12-point deduction if they fail.
Why did Everton misspend their finances? Because they were trying to compete. Oligarchs, sovereign wealth funds and American venture capitalist groups have raised the bar for investment so high that Mike Ashley — a man with a net worth of £3.84 billion according to the Sunday Times Rich List — felt he could not participate as Newcastle United owner. So in came a sovereign wealth fund, and now they’re in the mix. But that doesn’t make it any easier for Everton.
The group trying to buy Everton, 777 Partners, approached Newcastle’s owners on hearing they were interested in a multi-club model. It owns stakes in clubs including Genoa, Vasco Da Gama, Hertha Berlin and Standard Liège and thought this would give the Public Investment Fund of Saudi Arabia a ready-made package. Newcastle were not interested, but it shows what is needed to get a seat around the table these days. 777 Partners was hoping to obtain Saudi investment by proxy to make its takeover work. If this deal now stalls — although there is no suggestion 777 has lost interest — what is Everton’s owner, Farhad Moshiri, to do? This is a desperate club, a club in crisis that has made huge mistakes.
At which point in comes the Premier League with its helpful 12-point deduction. Not a fine, or a transfer embargo. A plunge through the trapdoor. And it may be argued this is merely a negotiating tool. Ask for 12, get six. The league may think if it makes no demand at all it runs the risk of a repeat of the West Ham and Sheffield United saga of 2007, following an initially weak ruling over third-party interference. Yet be careful what you wish for — you may get it. And would it serve as a deterrent? Not really, because the need to compete remains.