Bigmaclad
No mate
I don´t think so.
He left Liverpool with a positive net spending (after the sale of Torres), with a CL trophy and with coming closer to winning the premiership in 2005-2006 than they´ve ever done since.
Apart from that, Liverpool under Benitez, just as Chelsea under Benitez, always were at their best when it mattered the most. As a bonus, his teams can actually defend and aren´t absolutely sucking in goals like Martinezes Wigan.
He also left them with a side that was a shadow of when he started, and they've not recovered since. All thought his cup record is impressive, we need a manager that will build on what Moyes has done, not dismantle it