Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Confirmed Signing Neal Maupay

Status
Not open for further replies.
I wish people could chill a little.

Maupay is of course not going to start. Even if available, he is not going to get more than 10 or 15 minutes.

Teams train together. Working on movements. Working on relations. Have designated tasks both with and without the ball. To throw in a player that has not trained with the team is much more likely to harm the team than to make anything better.

It is also important to try to maximise the chances for a player to be success. A good start is helpful. A bad start in a new club is a potential disaster.

Look what other clubs do. Spurs did their business early. The only new player that has started a match is Perisic that Conte new form Inter. Scamacca at West Ham is an Italy international and a £35M signing. Eased into action and have not started in the league for a struggling West Ham.

Nunez cost a ton of money but was carefully matched by Klopp. And when the injury situation was so bad that Nunez had to start, it did cost the team. Big time.

Bournemouth signed an Argentina international and gave him first start last weekend. It took less than five minutes before his mistake caused a goal against. He was subbed off at half time.

We are playing Brentford tomorrow. They made exciting signings this summer in Lewis-Potter and Damsgaard. None of them are starting league matches yet.

Whether Maupay starts or not tomorrow will hardly do any difference for the chances of getting a result. He has zero minutes of football this season.

Way too often have Everton threw players that is not ready into the starting eleven. Not giving them a chance to get a good start. Ruined their confidence.

Maupay is probably a £30-35M investment. The club need to think long term.
I disagree with pretty much all of this.

I agree with the principal that you don’t rush in young players from other countries like Onana but Maupay is 26 and has three seasons premier league experience - he’s ready to go and will instantly do better than Rondon because he’s a better player.

Experienced premier league players getting thrown in is different to your examples, Gareth Barry for example, started the day after he signed for us if I recall and was boss.
 
At this stage, any striker will do. It would be hard to find a striker worse than Rondon. Signing Brighton's back up striker is not exactly what I hoped for but it is better than what we have.

Looking at what he has achieved at Brighton, it would be a surprise if he gets 10 goals here. If it is Maupay or Brereton Diaz, we should prioritise Brereton Diaz who at least has room for potential.
 
How have we gone from a front 3 of Richy/Dom/James to one of Gray/Maupay/McNeill?

Well when the 19/20 season started under Carlo our front three was Richarlison DCL James

Until DCL is fit our starting front three now is most likely to be Gray Maupay McNeill
although judging from Franks presser it seems like Gordon may stay so best case we might be looking at Gray DCL Gordon.

I know we couldn’t afford James and we had to sell Richarlison but it still feels like a downgrade in quality.
 
…but we had £20m to spend on McNeil & then bring in another left sided player as well as a CB and a £30m midfielder.
I think we really wanted Broja as competition mate, I now think we have decided he won't be coming so went to the next one
 

Funny how a lot of posters are saying he's better than Rondon, as if that's a benchmark, it's not,it's the very minimum.
He's MUCH better than Rondon and that isn't even a 'benchmark' - it's simply stating a fact.

He's another clear upgrade on the squad which is all we need to be aiming for at this point. Happy days.
 

You said he barely starts a game for them. Richarlison only started 3 more games than him in the league last season.

i said hes not one of their best players, he barely starts a game for them.
i stand by both, hes started 1 of their last 10 premier league games
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top