Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Next manager discussion (poll reset 21/05/2016)

Who would you want?

  • Frank de Boer

    Votes: 302 17.0%
  • David Moyes

    Votes: 56 3.2%
  • Manuel Pellegrini

    Votes: 152 8.6%
  • Ronald Koeman

    Votes: 286 16.1%
  • Other (please state below)

    Votes: 109 6.1%
  • Unai Emery

    Votes: 870 49.0%

  • Total voters
    1,775
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Let the Moyesiah finish the job he started. Come home Davey all is forgiven. 'Ooaaah David Moyes....

Yeah so that bucket and the cement, are you pouring or should I go first? Shows you how expectations have been managed to the extent, that even when he went to Man Utd and had the budget, he failed. But the mindset by some is, let's go back, we were competing then.

That wasn't pride, success or even competing, it was a systematic dismantling of our position within the game and the lowering of expectations after the boardroom disaster management of the 90's.

In that time thankfully we had a real true blue in Royle and at the start in Harvey who tried their best but it's time to look outside, former players though. If the Board have any sense, they'll look at the top four in the poll above and listen to the supporters for a change.
 
Well I voted for Eddie Howe. I know it's not the most popular choice and he's hardly the big name we're craving. However, Keeping Bournemouth up this season despite injuries has been an unreal achievement and I'd imagine he's watched Everton a lot this season and has a good idea in his head as to what he'd change. Anyone else vote for him? Don't be mean now.
JimmyJeffers I really do hope and believe that we will now go for someone who is proven., Eddie Howe as done well but he's won nothing he's managing a tiny club, it would be a disaster if he was appointed. Everton compared to Bournemouth? come on, you must be joking. Who could he attract? what is success under a manager like him? We would be the laughing stock. It's not gonna happen. Have faith I do I really believe this is the turning point for us.
 
I have a question, How do we get rid of Moyes ?

White hankies, tennis balls, cushions raining down from the Main Stand, Grim Repear costume in the enclosure, aeroplane banners, one way ticket to Celtic, or the old favourite... Boooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo :)
 
JimmyJeffers I really do hope and believe that we will now go for someone who is proven., Eddie Howe as done well but he's won nothing he's managing a tiny club, it would be a disaster if he was appointed. Everton compared to Bournemouth? come on, you must be joking. Who could he attract? what is success under a manager like him? We would be the laughing stock. It's not gonna happen. Have faith I do I really believe this is the turning point for us.
I disagree mate. I see shouts for pellegrini and man city should really have walked the league this season. Anyways, it's not a choice I have massive confidence in and I know that if we don't appoint a big name we'll lose Lukaku for sure but I find the rest of the names on the list fairly uninspiring (and I don't really know much about some of them to be fair)
 

The idea of Moyes worries me massively. I think I would throw in the towel with all this if he took charge again.

My concern with him getting the job is it's weird how Martinez took that shot at him about 10 years of being "mediocre" - almost like he "knows" something and is bitter about it.
 
Who's your shout mate? Come on. Cards on the table

I would hope we would be a bit more ambitious than Eddy Howe.

I quite like the idea of De Boer, it sends a statement, along with his coaching staff, that could be awesome. I would also not be adverse to Mancini, Pelligrini, or now Favre having read what I have about him.

The media meltdown if we got Mourinho would be a joy to behold too though, but not sure he is what we need. Does a job for 2 years and then it all goes sour.
 
I hear what you're saying but if we look at Pochettino at Spurs and even Ranieri at Leicester it seems that it's not necessarily a huge name that's needed. And to be honest many of the other names that have been shouted out have under achieved in recent times and we need someone who can over achieve and quickly imho

Mate our mentality has to change or the club never will. We have to act big now be big and show we mean business moshri is a billionaire by no fluke, I expect him to show how ambitious he and us are. Evertons nxt managerial appt has to be a winner it's as simple as that
 
I disagree mate. I see shouts for pellegrini and man city should really have walked the league this season. Anyways, it's not a choice I have massive confidence in and I know that if we don't appoint a big name we'll lose Lukaku for sure but I find the rest of the names on the list fairly uninspiring (and I don't really know much about some of them to be fair)

Had City not hired Guardiola and announced it publicly cutting the legs from under Pelligrini then who knows how the league would have finished up this season for City mate, at the time they did that City where 3 points away from the top

at the time of the announcement City had a run of 6/7 unbeaten game in the league in a row, had progressed to the CL knockout rounds for the first time, had won the SF against us and progressed in the FA Cup as well

They announced that Guardiola was taking charge and got beat in Manchester by Leicester and Spurs back to back and then battered in the FA cup by Chelsea, the board obviously thought - wrongly - that the Guardiola announcement timed for that run of games would give the squad a big boost - it had the complete opposite effect on them - maybe showing how popular a figure Pelligrini is at the club, a huge amount of the blame for Citues failing this season has to go on their board/owner for the timing of that decision
 

Mate our mentality has to change or the club never will. We have to act big now be big and show we mean business moshri is a billionaire by no fluke, I expect him to show how ambitious he and us are. Evertons nxt managerial appt has to be a winner it's as simple as that
Look, I doubt we'd go in for Howe but he makes more sense than some other names I think and a big name will certainly not guarantee success. Ploughing a lone furrow here. Who's your shout?
 
Look, I doubt we'd go in for Howe but he makes more sense than some other names I think and a big name will certainly not guarantee success. Ploughing a lone furrow here. Who's your shout?

Jose pellegrini de boer. If we don't get any of them Il be disappointed

No steady manager or up and coming or a safe bet one. That's going backwards
 
Had City not hired Guardiola and announced it publicly cutting the legs from under Pelligrini then who knows how the league would have finished up this season for City mate, at the time they did that City where 3 points away from the top

at the time of the announcement City had a run of 6/7 unbeaten game in the league in a row, had progressed to the CL knockout rounds for the first time, had won the SF against us and progressed in the FA Cup as well

They announced that Guardiola was taking charge and got beat in Manchester by Leicester and Spurs back to back and then battered in the FA cup by Chelsea, the board obviously thought - wrongly - that the Guardiola announcement timed for that run of games would give the squad a big boost - it had the complete opposite effect on them - maybe showing how popular a figure Pelligrini is at the club, a huge amount of the blame for Citues failing this season has to go on their board/owner for the timing of that decision
Fair play. Seem to remember them doing worse before the announcement for some reason.
 
Yeah so that bucket and the cement, are you pouring or should I go first? Shows you how expectations have been managed to the extent, that even when he went to Man Utd and had the budget, he failed. But the mindset by some is, let's go back, we were competing then.

That wasn't pride, success or even competing, it was a systematic dismantling of our position within the game and the lowering of expectations after the boardroom disaster management of the 90's.

In that time thankfully we had a real true blue in Royle and at the start in Harvey who tried their best but it's time to look outside, former players though. If the Board have any sense, they'll look at the top four in the poll above and listen to the supporters for a change.

You need to divorce Moyes from the board mate. The reason we haven't competed in the premier league is because of Bill Kenwright and the board no one else. They were not in any way ready for the premier league and when it began we were a walking relegation time bomb likely to go off at any point.

It is my firm belief that had Moyes not been appointed we would have remained that way. We were on our way down in 02/03. All that happened in the following years were our best players getting sold every year and loan players coming in. Selling Arteta just to service a loan was criminal. Had we had a fraud like Martinez in charge we would have gone down and who knows what that would have meant given our precarious financial position. We could have been Portsmouth or Leeds.

Instead the entire house of cards was held together by one person. A manager who went out and found genuine top 6 quality time and time again for bargain basement prices. Not only did he achieve a brilliant feat of keeping us in the league as the board floggedour assets, he had us up competing for Europe and going on cup runs.

Short memories led to fans thinking that it was 1987 everything was boss then suddenly Moyes ruined everything. Absolute rubbish. As an Evertonian I will be forever grateful for David Moyes. Times are different now, the financial picture is incomparable, maybe he's not the manager we need now, but in 2003 he was THE manager we needed and single habdedly put this club back on an even footing. You only have to see how teams who when Moyes started were miles ahead of us Leeds, Villa, Newcastle even with a load of money, their pick of players and managers, have declined horrifically. At the same time some of our fans were moaning about the glass ceiling and only beating City out of the top 4.

I honestly find criticism of the majority of Moyes' time at Everton utterly embarassing. To say he 'systematically dismantled our position in the game' is absolutely erroneous. If you want a real definition of that look no further than our current manager undoing a decade of good work taking us back to the lower half of the premier league, disconnecting the fans from the players, making Goodison a laughing stock, languishing miles behind our neighbours. Just like the dark days of the first decade of premier league football. We could have been stuck with a joker like him in the exact moment that we were probably at the most vulnerable financial position in the entire history of the club. Instead we got a manager who gave us Europe on peanuts when others were spending loads, like coming fifth in a formula one race driving a clapped out mini. Yet it wasn't good enough for some was it.

Thank you David Moyes for saving Everton.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top