BarryDylan
Player Valuation: £50k
I must be honest, I am scared 
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
- Status
Yeah exactly. Kompany has the 'Guardiola protigee' tag going in his favour at the moment but he's done nothing in the top flight.
sdk
Player Valuation: £35m
Dyche brought Burnley up from the Championship twice, keeping them in the PL for a fair few years the second time.
Kompany is doing well with them in the Championship currently.
I don't understand how this shows Kompany to be superior to Dyche.
Eggsyblueskin
Player Valuation: £40m
I didn’t necessarily say it did.
But although he brought them up he also relegated them twice, (technically)
Subjectively I’ve never been an admirer of him or the type of limited football his Burnley team employed.
I would prefer to be sat watching Kompany’s Burnley than Dyches’.
I think any potential success would be more likely under the former rather than the latter
All that is immaterial as he is our manager at present tasked with preventing our relegation. and in the ground I am fully behind the team as ever , regardless of who the manager happens to be.
But, personally, next season whichever division we end up in, I hope we will have a new start behind a new board and a new manager.
Maupay was one of the best players in the Championship a few seasons ago. Its not all about aggression, it is more important that a manager plays players to their strengths
Surely it depends on what your definition of 'superior' is. Dyche and Kompany are very different managers. For a relegation battle and to get players to work their socks off and play effective football then I would consider Dyche the superior. For more entertaining football and trying to get a team to play 'sexy' football then I think Kompany would be superior. It all depends on the players a club has and the overall position a club is in and the footballing strategy being handed down by the board
I must be honest, I am scared
A nice soothing chat, with @matty1878 will help allay your fears mate.
You what! Is this really a thing?
Your whole opinion on Kompany as a manager is based on a few months at Burnley in the championship.
With that in mind, you can't be so conclusive.
HalfTimeSayers
Player Valuation: £30m
No idea why the Championship gets labelled as tough and aggressive. It just isn’t, it’s lower quality. PL clubs have young strikers who aren’t equipped to deal with PL defenders so they send them down on loan into the Championship. They don’t all return covered in scars and with cabbage ears and missing teeth, staying in digs with an old pervert. Same with young defenders.
Sexy Marco’s Fulham didn’t romp it by carrying knives to away matches.
The Chamionship isn’t tough to get back out of because they are all hardmen and you play 486 games every week on boggy pitches. It’s hard because the second you go down the majority of your PL quality players leave and you become just another Championship team.
Sexy Marco’s Fulham didn’t romp it by carrying knives to away matches.
The Chamionship isn’t tough to get back out of because they are all hardmen and you play 486 games every week on boggy pitches. It’s hard because the second you go down the majority of your PL quality players leave and you become just another Championship team.
blue_aussie05
Player Valuation: £8m
Fixed that for you, Mattyhello darkness my old friend
Drico
Player Valuation: £50m
That won't be a problem for us, then.
Saint Domingo
Player Valuation: £90m
On paper (I know I know) the weekend could be a very good one for us if we can just do our job and beat Brentford. Quite a few teams around us with very difficult fixtures.
I know, but that is all the data available. It is given when discussing a novice manager that he can only be judged on the limited games he has managed. But so far he has performed really well at Burnley and I expect he has shown enough potential for many PL clubs to be prepared to take a chance on him
- Status