Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Roberto Martinez discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree with the principle of what you're saying, but i think we have to believe there is a possibility of us competing at the top table - otherwise what's the point?

Because of the restrictions in place every Everton manager is aware that they will be expected to punch above their weight. It's not something which is sprung on them after taking the job, it will be very clear to them when they apply. Regularly finishing 10th is not acceptable for this club, and nor should it be. The same idea applies in all aspects of life too, if I said to my CEO that I was doing alright considering the limitations i was working under he would not take it too kindly i can assure you.

I agree, we have to be trying to punch above our weight. It's much easier said than done though as this is what everyone else is trying to do
 
yeah but who sets these expectations and just what are they

and again with the short version of my main argument; Moyes and Martinez are just different flavours of bang average

and that's exactly what we get...week...after week...after week...weak.

Well, hang on...

"Moyes and Martinez are just different flavours of bang average"

You must have some expectation levels of your own to have formed that opinion, so I'd be interested to know what those are and why you think they are realistic.
 
Why can't there be a shade of grey? Why does there have to be two camps and indeed people criticised for being in the middle? I don't like what I've currently seen from Martinez, but I'm also not really a fan of firing managers without giving him time. Do I want him out now? No, absolutely ludicrous kopite behaviour to do that at the start of a season. If we show no sign of improvement this season and the next would I consider it appropriate at the end of 2016/17? Yes. People can criticise what he's done so far but still want him to turn it around. Most people just want what's best for Everton. Some see that as a change in manager. What no one wants is for us to lose games just to get a manager out (which is what certain posters like to imply).
I wish it was that simple
I struggle with some of the comments as it is blatantly obvious people have made their minds up they want him out - very sad..
 
Well, hang on...

"Moyes and Martinez are just different flavours of bang average"

You must have some expectation levels of your own to have formed that opinion, so I'd be interested to know what those are and why you think they are realistic.

Personally my expectations are moulded by every ball I've seen kicked since 1960. I know what good players do, I know how good teams play and we're not doing it.

The Club /Team /Staff /Board (should) set the expectations, but there's no winners in this Club on or off the field that's why they are set to average and some days we struggle to do average...oh yes we have our high points and low points and they average out to...average

Supporters don't set them we just come along to watch the players and staff try to meet or exceed their own expectations.
any expectation we as supporters have should be based on if we think they will met or exceed theirs
 

Injury crisis;
3 long term out of how many players.
2 with short term knocks
Any others are bit part players at best

crisis? what crisis? - Degsy after Jim Callaghan

'Top Teams'? all of them? surely sir you jest and exaggerate for comic effect.

Top Teams; City, Chelsea and United....W1 D0 L2

Our Level; rs, Spurs W 0 D2 L0

Other Ranks; Watford, Southampton, Swansea, WBA. W2 D2 L0

If Roberto is as good as you all say we would've done better performance-wise and maybe even results-wise, but he isn't, so we didn't
and
it
won't
change

This season we could jump like Cahill and still only lightly brush the tips of our fingers on the bottom of 59Pts aka bang average

But me, what do I know in the face of all this near fundamentalist grade righteous certainty, this lack of absolute doubt.
I agree over the injuries if you look across the whole squad, but that would be blinkered outlook.
When you lose 3 internationals out of your back 4 any squad in the country would struggle, as it is something you cannot compensate for.

We will finish between 5th & 8th, as that is were we sit.

If you believe we should be a top 4 team you need to sit down in a dark room and reevaluate your aspirations.

money is the key to success, and we have a little but not enough
 
Personally my expectations are moulded by every ball I've seen kicked since 1960. I know what good players do, I know how good teams play and we're not doing it.

The Club /Team /Staff /Board (should) set the expectations, but there's no winners in this Club on or off the field that's why they are set to average and some days we struggle to do average...oh yes we have our high points and low points and they average out to...average

Supporters don't set them we just come along to watch the players and staff try to meet or exceed their own expectations.
any expectation we as supporters have should be based on if we think they will met or exceed theirs
You must of seen a fair few bad players to understand that everything can't be perfect and Rosie.
As for winners at the club, we have them in abundance but the big winner we don't have is that bloke called Pound Sterling.
Sadly gone are the days when a great manager can build a team from nothing, and with little or no money (Howard being a great example). The days we live in now is dominated by money and greedy players, sad state of affairs as we will never see a Forest or the likes coming from nowhere and winning trophies.
 
You can set expectations as high as you like, but surely there has to be a sense of realism about it when you do so.

The reality of the situation, is that under this board and as of now in the premier league, we cannot compete on a financial basis with the top 6 teams of United, City, Chelsea, Liverpool, and Arsenal. They have far more money than us, and as such can afford to have expensive failures as players and to fork out top $$$ for the best every year when things aren't going their way.

In order to compete on a level playing basis, either we need the board to make an investment of new capital into the playing staff (not going to happen), or we need to carefully and cannily build a team that can match those players. Not only just build a team but also keep the core group together over a longer period of time.
Even then achieving top 4 is a very tough ask because of the financial limitations on the club, let alone doing it consistently.
As of now we currently have some players who would not look remiss in a top four team, but lack the quality in depth to play at a top 4 level consistently when players are out injured and the squad is stretched. In order for this current team to achieve top 4 we'd be looking at a team playing very well, with injury luck and some bad luck on behalf of our competitors.

The manager for me has done a really good job in building a young squad with a high ceiling. Whether they will stay together long enough to reach that ceiling with us is unlikely unless we find some level of success as a group in this season.
He had one great year in which we genuinely challenged the top four, and on any other year might well have attained it. He had one poor year where we really underperformed (with perhaps some significant confounding factors).
For me anyway this is the year for him to prove that the first year wasn't a fluke and that we can compete at the top table under him.

TLdr People expecting us to get top four regularly are off their medication. Roberto has this season to prove we can compete for Europe under him.
 
You must of seen a fair few bad players to understand that everything can't be perfect and Rosie.
As for winners at the club, we have them in abundance but the big winner we don't have is that bloke called Pound Sterling.
Sadly gone are the days when a great manager can build a team from nothing, and with little or no money (Howard being a great example). The days we live in now is dominated by money and greedy players, sad state of affairs as we will never see a Forest or the likes coming from nowhere and winning trophies.

so because we don't have a billionaire Martinez gets a free pass for not being able to get the best out of the players

I've been trying for more than an hour to get onto the 'Fears of a witch hunt'
AND watch Fargo 2 which is shaping up better than average which is more than can be s

nah I'm off.
 

I have not said i want him out but the difference between me and you is i state his faults and am realistic,you think everything he does is wonderful.
He should have sorted the goalkeepig situation and its bad management not doing that but you pretend everything he does is perfect.
Be a man and admit when he makes mistakes.
He is not perfect by any means and i still worry about his management skills but like i said back in march i will give him a chance to do his job and learn the ropes which i am doing.
No need to dig me out when i have also praised him this season and mentioned the good things he has done.
I get the impression you are a bit of a drama queen who likes being muggy for the sake of it
You've wanted him out. Am I wrong on that?
 
Injury crisis;
3 long term out of how many players.
2 with short term knocks
Any others are bit part players at best

crisis? what crisis? - Degsy after Jim Callaghan

'Top Teams'? all of them? surely sir you jest and exaggerate for comic effect.

Top Teams; City, Chelsea and United....W1 D0 L2

Our Level; rs, Spurs W 0 D2 L0

Other Ranks; Watford, Southampton, Swansea, WBA. W2 D2 L0

If Roberto is as good as you all say we would've done better performance-wise and maybe even results-wise, but he isn't, so we didn't
and
it
won't
change

This season we could jump like Cahill and still only lightly brush the tips of our fingers on the bottom of 59Pts aka bang average

But me, what do I know in the face of all this near fundamentalist grade righteous certainty, this lack of absolute doubt.
'No injury crisis':

Injuries to

Baines
Pienaar
Cleverley
Coleman
Stones
Besic
Oviedo
Mirallas
Deulofeu

....I think we can safely say that a fairly small first team squad has been massively hit by injury.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top