Roberto Martinez discussion

joey_macmo · October 29, 2015

Someone said this

Howe, Tuchel, Bielsa, Bilić and De Boer are a real possibilites. And these are not bad names to be honest.

and you replied

De Boer is the only choice from that list. And even then it's a massive risk.

the search brings this up from Davek too

This has to be THE thread that'll be mined for mirth next season when the Bobby Brown Shoes hero worship is back on track again.

Tommy Tuchel and Eddie Howe.

FFS.

*bookmarked*

ijjysmith · October 29, 2015

joey_macmo said:
Someone said this

and you replied

the search brings this up from Davek too

I talk loads of bollox mate.

And I'm talking about possibilities now. I'm fairly sure he wouldn't leave Dortmund for us.

Would he?

daz4matty · October 29, 2015

ijjysmith said:
We'd lose 3-0 at home to Everton.

Your on fire tonight ha ha

joey_macmo · October 29, 2015

ijjysmith said:
I talk loads of bollox mate.

i don't want the manager out like nor do i think it will happen but there are always candidates out there

ijjysmith · October 29, 2015

joey_macmo said:
i don't want the manager out like nor do i think it will happen but there are always candidates out there

None that I can think of.

Well no good ones. And a lot of crap ones.

davek · October 29, 2015

joey_macmo said:
Someone said this

and you replied

the search brings this up from Davek too

I'm I supposed to have been proven wrong?

Howe - well out of his depth.
Tuchel - 10 games into a two horse race and he's lost the title already.

*sigh*

joey_macmo · October 29, 2015

ijjysmith said:
None that I can think of.

again you said the same last year and there quite blatantly were

davek · October 29, 2015

mikeh72 said:
Of course we'd sooner listen to rudden, as he gets his point across without being a high and mighty, condescending, tripe chatting clown about it

Well at least you might have learnt something then. I'm thankful for small mercies.

joey_macmo · October 29, 2015

davek said:
I'm I supposed to have been proven wrong?

Howe - well out of his depth.
Tuchel - 10 games into a two horse race and he's lost the title already.

*sigh*

was talking about you not to you

ijjysmith · October 29, 2015

joey_macmo said:
again you said the same last year and there quite blatantly were

Who could we get right now who would be better?

That's literally all I'm asking.

Tubey · October 29, 2015

ijjysmith said:
Who could we get right now who would be better?

That's literally all I'm asking.

There's no way of knowing as they aren't in the job. Anyone could be better or worse.

It's a terrible counter-argument that is used all the time, and indeed was used liberally to defend Moyes.

ijjysmith · October 29, 2015

Tubey said:
There's no way of knowing as they aren't in the job. Anyone could be better or worse.

It's a terrible counter-argument that is used all the time, and indeed was used liberally to defend Moyes.

I'm just after some possibly names. That's all.

Dithering Dougie · October 29, 2015

ijjysmith said:
I'm just after some possibly names. That's all.

Redknapp, Rodgers, Sherwood...

*.shudders

Tubey · October 29, 2015

ijjysmith said:
I'm just after some possibly names. That's all.

You're asking "who would be better?" - the answer is "there's absolutely no way of telling".

There was no way of knowing a manager from the Championship managing Preston would be better than a well respected title winning manager named Walter Smith.

Similarly, there was no way of knowing a manager who led a team into the Second Division with Blackburn and had hardly any managerial experience would be better than a man who had been managing Everton for over 200 games. But Howard Kendall did indeed turn out to be a step up from Gordon Lee.