Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Roberto Martinez discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't get all this the penalty was a turning point, we were still 2-0 up and bossed the game up to the penalty, why do any of the players heads go down or it affects them, they are still 2-0 up.

Just shut up shop, see the game out, bring on an extra midfielder, Pulis was 1-0 up playing against 10 men Man U and he brought a forward off to pack the midfield with another body in there.

I've never seen Martinez in 3 season shut up shop, protect what he's got, and by god we've lost enough commanding positions in games for him to learn it's got to be done sometimes, attack, attack, attack does not work, you need a balance.
 
45 points lost from winning positions in his tenure


45 pts...In little under three seasons. Which could easily accumulate by then, too, given our benevolently schizophrenic nature

Averages out at 15pts per season if it stays the same. A lower-ranking club's entire season's tally that we've managed to fritter away.

And he still hasn't learnt from it, nor done anything to address it.

There must some sort of mental deficiency imo.
 
You underestimate @davek .

He will have that picked to pieces within 10 minutes.
AQ-Khan-on-Science-and-Education-cover.jpg
 
I don't get all this the penalty was a turning point, we were still 2-0 up and bossed the game up to the penalty, why do any of the players heads go down or it affects them, they are still 2-0 up.

Just shut up shop, see the game out, bring on an extra midfielder, Pulis was 1-0 up playing against 10 men Man U and he brought a forward off to pack the midfield with another body in there.

I've never seen Martinez in 3 season shut up shop, protect what he's got, and by god we've lost enough commanding positions in games for him to learn it's got to be done sometimes, attack, attack, attack does not work, you need a balance.

And yet when he does make a decensive sub (Barry for Rom) we still concede with both DM's losing track of Payet.

Barry and Besic are getting off quite easy IMO.
 

I don't get all this the penalty was a turning point, we were still 2-0 up and bossed the game up to the penalty, why do any of the players heads go down or it affects them, they are still 2-0 up.

Just shut up shop, see the game out, bring on an extra midfielder, Pulis was 1-0 up playing against 10 men Man U and he brought a forward off to pack the midfield with another body in there.

I've never seen Martinez in 3 season shut up shop, protect what he's got, and by god we've lost enough commanding positions in games for him to learn it's got to be done sometimes, attack, attack, attack does not work, you need a balance.
I'm no psychologist mate but you can't deny that missing penalties in a match affects how you perceive the rest of the match. I get that we were 2-0 up and so it shouldn't be an excuse but I don't think you can deny that it knocks the players' confidence a bit.
 
I'm no psychologist mate but you can't deny that missing penalties in a match affects how you perceive the rest of the match. I get that we were 2-0 up and so it shouldn't be an excuse but I don't think you can deny that it knocks the players' confidence a bit.
I am denying it, we've bossed the game and are 2-0 up, missing a Pen should not mean draw or defeat at 2-0 up FFS.
 
I am denying it, we've bossed the game and are 2-0 up, missing a Pen should not mean draw or defeat at 2-0 up FFS.
Are our players robots? It's natural that they react negatively and get distracted by a missed penalty, it is human nature. The same feelings of frustration and disappointment we all felt as fans they will be feeling as players on the pitch because they want us to win as well.
 

I'm no psychologist mate but you can't deny that missing penalties in a match affects how you perceive the rest of the match. I get that we were 2-0 up and so it shouldn't be an excuse but I don't think you can deny that it knocks the players' confidence a bit.

Dents Lukaku's confidence i can probably accept, however everyone knew from the moment we missed that West Ham would get a boost and put pressure on us, that was the moment to change the game and shut up shop.

Martinez didn't, we lost.

I don't normally read the Metro - but i seen the below article on newsnow about how Martinez should get the sack and read this...

"
‘You don’t win games by changing the style. You win games by being very, very good at what you do and changing only brings doubts.’

That was Roberto Martinez back in December 2014, with his Everton side in the midst of a slump in form that had seen them lose three games in a row over Christmas. It would later become four after a miserable 2-0 loss at Hull on New Year’s Day.

"


Read more: http://metro.co.uk/2016/03/09/rober...him-closer-to-the-sack-5742208/#ixzz42Q5TBtqY

He isn't changing his style, his removal of Lennon for Niasse while the wrong sub was an almost stamp of his feet that his style is one he removes to change from.
 
The most goals conceded at home of any team in the top 6 leagues in Europe
45 points lost from winning positions in his tenure
More losses at home than in Moyes last 3 seasons

Middle ranking?
Positions finished in Moyes last 7 seasons 6,5,5,8,7,7,6, a mean of 6th - which however way you want to look at it isn't middle ranking it's top 30% of the league taken from 7 seasons so its no fluke, usually enough for a good shot at qualifying for Europe, 8th highest paying in wages which has been our consistant position the past 3 seasons - so not too moderately backed on that count.

If we are going to think of Everton as middle ranking then maybe the reason is a manager who looks like having 2 consecutive bottom half finishes has a part to play in that.

Well, we can all play the 'last seven seasons' for this and 'last three seasons' for that game and make a point of sorts. Fundamentally we are a middling PL club - nowhere near the elite, but nowhere near relegation fodder. Right slap bang in the middle on a sliding scal that goes from 6th or 7th to 10th/11th.

We have a reasonable but average type of spend and we tread water for the most part. I mean, if that isn't true, why is there excitement about the Moshiri deal taking us to the next level?

Manager of 'this quality' - exactly what quality is that Dave? Seriously a manager who has managed two achievements of note in his 7 years in the top flight, the 72 point trophy, and the fa cup, to counter both those though, the 72 point trophy saw us beat Arsenal to have 4th in our own hands and we absolutely bottled it with some bizarre managerial decisions thrown in to help (resting McCarthy lol), and the fa cup came at the cost of being relegated.

What quality is he showing where it really matters - the results - the quality to get 5th then 11th and now be sat in 12th Dave?

You see, this is why I cant take these attacks on Martinez seriously. Even a season that saw him smash through our PL points total record by 7 clear points you find room to attempt to belittle it. It's just nonsensical as an argument to try and unpick that season and say it fell short - Martinez squeezed that season dry and got a total that in many other seasons was a CL spot nailed on.

Maybe you wont see it as an achievement, but more level heads unaffected by forum fever will.

Maybe the new owner will aspire to more than style over substance - which is exactly what martinez is btw, all style no substance, why should we sack him - can sum it up in one simple sentence mate, we should sack him because he has shown now he is not good enough for the job

More style than substance. The feller's built a PL club from ashes and put the most prestigious domestic cup in world football in a trophy cabinet belonging to a gang of pie eaters. Maybe that's not substantial enough and we should have one of the new flavours in who had half a good PL season or managed a team in the white heat of the Eridivise or Ligue 1.
 
Dents Lukaku's confidence i can probably accept, however everyone knew from the moment we missed that West Ham would get a boost and put pressure on us, that was the moment to change the game and shut up shop.

Martinez didn't, we lost.


To be fair Rom upped his game even more after the penno.

One run in particular he brushed defenders off the ball as if they were flies and it took a tasty save from Adrian to stop him scoring.
 
]
[
Dents Lukaku's confidence i can probably accept, however everyone knew from the moment we missed that West Ham would get a boost and put pressure on us, that was the moment to change the game and shut up shop.

Martinez didn't, we lost.

I don't normally read the Metro - but i seen the below article about how Martinez should get the sack and read this...

"
‘You don’t win games by changing the style. You win games by being very, very good at what you do and changing only brings doubts.’

That was Roberto Martinez back in December 2014, with his Everton side in the midst of a slump in form that had seen them lose three games in a row over Christmas. It would later become four after a miserable 2-0 loss at Hull on New Year’s Day.

"


Read more: http://metro.co.uk/2016/03/09/rober...him-closer-to-the-sack-5742208/#ixzz42Q5TBtqY

He isn't changing his style, his removal of Lennon for Niasse while the wrong sub was an almost stamp of his feet that his style is one he removes to change from.

Tbf mate, I do think RM tried to shut up shop. It's just that Niasse for Lennon was his way of doing it, which is mental.
 
Are our players robots? It's natural that they react negatively and get distracted by a missed penalty, it is human nature. The same feelings of frustration and disappointment we all felt as fans they will be feeling as players on the pitch because they want us to win as well.
When we missed the Pen we as fans didn't think oh that's it now, we are going to lose, 2-0 up in command all game West Ham had created nothing up to then.

The Pen was a bonus, icing on the cake if scored, missing it should not have mattered, it's crazy to think otherwise.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top