Your spot on regards the weight issue. He has too much muscle which is affecting both his mobility and endurance. He’s football’s version of Frank Bruno. The sweat is always pouring off him early in games.
He’s a very good striker, and his touch isn’t as bad as some make out (been guilty of it myself), but he’s not among the top bracket of forwards. He’s not starting for United and no-one is batting an eyelid.
Don’t know where he’d go after United. If he somehow loses that weight he’s carrying around the field maybe he could come good.
The problem with him scoring more goals for Everton is it the style of play was geared towards him, a style that doesn’t win you pots. Get it in the mixer for the big unit to get on the end off, that method of play is not challenging top sides. It needs more quick interplay, a style he struggles with.
Spot on post mate put far better than I did it's a shame really, when younger he had the potential to go right to the top he just hit a brick wall, Everton were his level, though maybe not now.
Don't think I'd want him back now, we play more like a team and not just to his strengths, as you said, football has moved on, a top team can't rely on one man.