Fair comment, knocked out of both cups early & doing what you would expect in the league. He's doing a decent job, nothing more.
Actually, bearing in mind the naff pre-season we had due to the problems in the transfer window, added to him having to start the season with half of the uber gash left to him by his predecessor, I would say he is doing rather a splendid job myself.
He has improved the side defensively and offensively in half a season and that is undeniable.
He has offloaded all of the absolute pap left to him and brought kids into the side whom he has given confidence to.
He looks like he has finally able to get the best out of Barkley, who we all wanted to be our talisman but was going nowhere due to two years of being completely mismanaged.
He has installed discipline back into a side that looked an absolute rag-bag outfit, remember Anfield last season and Leicester away? We were the laughing stock and totally all at sea!
So when you weigh it up like that, he is exceeding the expectations bestowed upon him and then some more.