Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Ronald Koeman

Ronald Koeman...good choice for us?

  • yes, he'll get us top 6 and stability

  • no, it's uninspiring even if top 6 is back on

  • josé on toast


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
just seen that he has said his future lays with Southampton. If we did get him in I wouldn't complain, more proven than De Boer
 
I say body language.
Specifically it was his eye contact or complete lack of it when saying 'yes' he was staying.
Throughout the rest of the questioning he was looking directly at the press.
Have a look for yourself.
 
Here are some facts for the Southampton fans reading:

Southampton

1 (Yes, just the 1) FA Cup
39 seasons of top flight football
1,567 top flight points
Multiple spells in the third tier, including very recently.
32 505 capacity stadium
2014-15 revenue of £113.7m
Two decent finishes in the last two seasons (7-8), look on for another decent finish this season (7-8).

Everton

9 times champions of England
5 FA Cups
1 European Cup winners cup
113 seasons of top flight football (comfortably the most)
4,402 top flight points
39571 capacity stadium
2014-15 revenue of £125.6m
A poor finish of 11th last season. Currently 12th.
@ijjysmith

Print this out and pin it next to your work computer.
 

Here are some facts for the Southampton fans reading:

Southampton

1 (Yes, just the 1) FA Cup
39 seasons of top flight football
1,567 top flight points
Multiple spells in the third tier, including very recently.
32 505 capacity stadium
2014-15 revenue of £113.7m
Two decent finishes in the last two seasons (7-8), look on for another decent finish this season (7-8).

Everton

9 times champions of England
5 FA Cups
1 European Cup winners cup
113 seasons of top flight football (comfortably the most)
4,402 top flight points
39571 capacity stadium
2014-15 revenue of £125.6m
A poor finish of 11th last season. Currently 12th.

Apparently though "history means nothing". ;)
 
Why do you think that? You could more easily say it encourages a positive discussion as the negative option still admits we look likely to make top 6, with more stable team performances. After two disordered seasons in the bottom half that's encouraging, no?

Ideally, top 6 is where we need to be, for that way lies European adventures. I think most agree Koeman is a likely candidate to put us back there, based on his last two seasons at Saints.

The case for "no" is that a high-end Prem-winning candidate like Pellegrini or Mancini would be expected to get us top 4 straightaway, and that this is more desirable as it aims higher quicker. This logic also makes sense as by waiting too long we give the other big clubs a chance to regroup after this strange season: by the time Koeman's Everton is ready for top-4 we may have 5 or 6 really strong rivals.


I went for josé-on-toast...no José no party.

That poll suggests the best possible outcome should Koeman take over is 6th and stability. Fortunately that's not the case.

The idea that Koeman would be in any way limited to bringing us to 6th-placed positions when backed with resources dwarfing those he currently achieves them with with is, happily, based on flawed logic and I look forward to that penny dropping on here in due course.
 
In what respect? Because he is 8 years younger? Unless you expect a 20 year stint at the helm I think either is capable of a long term project given the chance. I just have reservations about De Boer's lack of experience in a decent league. And he looks like the type of manager that'll upsticks as soon as a 'big' club comes knocking. (Not that Koeman won't if he does that to Southampton to come to us!)

Nothing to do with age, couldn't tell you how old ether of them are.

Because look at Koeman at Southampton, not committing to a new contract, keeping his options open. Nothing wrong with that but he's waiting for a better deal elsewhere. And I think he'd do that here too.
 

That poll suggests the best possible outcome should Koeman take over is 6th and stability. Fortunately that's not the case.

The idea that Koeman would be in any way limited to bringing us to 6th-placed positions when backed with resources dwarfing those he currently achieves them with with is, happily, based on completely flawed logic and I look forward to that penny dropping on here in due course.

Top 6 isn't necessarily the same as 6th. But still top 6 (including 6th place) will be the target for Koeman during his first couple seasons as Everton manager, and it's a realistic one.

And since when is stability a negative thing?
 
Nothing to do with age, couldn't tell you how old ether of them are.

Because look at Koeman at Southampton, not committing to a new contract, keeping his options open. Nothing wrong with that but he's waiting for a better deal elsewhere. And I think he'd do that here too.

Of course Moyes did that too. Managers will always want to climb the ladder, it's like that in every business. Koeman is like a gypsy, likes to move ground
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top