I agree, but to take a 20 year old to the World Cup after he'd had what I would say was a decent season (some excellent performances, some pretty poor) and then keep him in the team throughout a generally poor season, shows that hodgson has much more faith in him than most managers would.
Yeah he talks him down but sometimes I think that's important. He gets a lot of carrot at everton and sometimes the odd stick is no bad thing.
To be clear, I think hodgson is a dinosaur in general terms, but I don't agree with the idea he gives Ross a raw deal.