Personally thought he was our tailisman and very under rated in that regard. Never helped him being used as Cahill's replacement because Moyes had officially ran out of ideas at that point in how to put a team out with the players he had.
Not a 27 million pound player i dopnt think no, a 15 million one yes easily. But to be fair the way i see it, Martinez sold him (no matter how likeley united buying him was) because he didn't fit into his system and bought McCarthy who did, a great example of a good managerial decision.