dannyboy
Player Valuation: £60m
Who are we dropping him for? Kenny isn't ready/never will be.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
2018/19 Seamus Coleman
- Thread starter dublinbluenose
- Start date
- Status
Who are we dropping him for? Kenny isn't ready/never will be.
mkrudden
Player Valuation: £40m
Hmmm. I'm not writing him off. In isolation tonight though he was off the pace.
I didn't like how he responded to the first goal. Seemed flat. His body position for the second goal was all wrong too.
Mina was having to give him a gee up when we got our penalty which shouldn't be needed for our captain.
I thought he was excellent vs Liverpool though so happy to just put tonight down as a poor one.
I didn't like how he responded to the first goal. Seemed flat. His body position for the second goal was all wrong too.
Mina was having to give him a gee up when we got our penalty which shouldn't be needed for our captain.
I thought he was excellent vs Liverpool though so happy to just put tonight down as a poor one.
Jamalio Danubio DiCanio
Player Valuation: £950k
There's got to be some doubts about him after such a big injury.
However, I'd be inclined to give him time. I think with such a long period of not playing football it may be that he needs a good few months of solid football to get back to his top level. He's 30 at the moment so has a good few years left in him if he can regain anywhere near his best form.
Bigger question may be around the high intensity our full backs are asked to play at. Is it reasonable to expect 2 lads (Digne and Coleman) to carry that load over an entire season? The need for some quality replacements may be necessary since we ask them to get up and down the pitch a lot. Gives an opportunity to rest them but also to keep them on their toes.
ToffeeLee1878
Player Valuation: £8m
Coleman been a terrific player but injury has changed him as a player,hardly ever gets overlapping apart from one run in the first half last night,and the own goal made him withdraw even more into himself ,doesn’t take much for his morale to slump
welshtoffee
Player Valuation: £20m
Was very poor last night, it wont take many more performances like that for the crowd to turn against him, i know a section of the upper Bullens where i was sitting was baying for his blood late on in the match.
Strikinglyhandsome1
Player Valuation: £5m
Silva has his own problems with the Irish backstop.
How about isolate his entire season so far; last night was just a microcosm of it.
mkrudden
Player Valuation: £40m
He's been inconsistent at worst.
As I say, vs Liverpool he was very good. That was a week ago. He has also been in other games too.
He has been OK. We have more pressing concerns but I expect by this time next season he won't be first choice
Good to see everyone applying some well-earned loyalty to one of our most reliable players of the past 10 years, who is still finding his way after a potentially career-ending injury. Family club only when it suits.
It's going to be pretty rancid going the match when the booing melts come for Coleman.
It's going to be pretty rancid going the match when the booing melts come for Coleman.
EFC78
Player Valuation: £25m
Not sure why he's getting so much criticism for last night. He contributed to our first goal and he was linking up well with Walcott at times in the first half.
I think at times his unorthodox clumsy style can frustrate the fans as the first goal may have been prevented but it was still extremely unlucky. The second was a complete mismatch in height so he had no chance with that, and you have to look at the defending from the others to allow that chance to develop. I think there were bigger issues in the team last night.
I think at times his unorthodox clumsy style can frustrate the fans as the first goal may have been prevented but it was still extremely unlucky. The second was a complete mismatch in height so he had no chance with that, and you have to look at the defending from the others to allow that chance to develop. I think there were bigger issues in the team last night.
bol-uk
Player Valuation: £50m
davids
Player Valuation: £70m
Sentiment has no place in the modern game,and if we want to make the step to the next level as eveybody seems to be posting,then players who have three average games in four need replacing.Luckily for Coleman we don't have a replacement at the moment.
- Status