2021/22 Seamus Coleman

[MikeH72]

If that fraud Ferguson is handed *legnedary* status then this lad Coleman is a God and needs a statue made of him.

I don’t get you sometimes Dave. You wrote Baines off as a club icon because he’s never won a trophy, yet Ferguson has won a trophy and when someone calls him a club icon you dismiss him in favour of Seamus Coleman who’s won absolutely naff all and never come close?

 

[Joey66]

No icon of mine.

Went missing in a season we had a knife at our throats.

Agent Johnson mate .....

 

[davek]

I don’t get you sometimes Dave. You wrote Baines off as a club icon because he’s never won a trophy, yet Ferguson has won a trophy and when someone calls him a club icon you dismiss him in favour of Seamus Coleman who’s won absolutely naff all and never come close?

He played a few minutes in a cup final that was already won.

 

[MikeH72]

He played a few minutes in a cup final that was already won.

Of course, because an FA Cup campaign is 1 game.

Coleman hasn’t played a second in a trophy winning team either. Been here longer and played more games than Ferguson, played with better players.

 

[davek]

Agent Johnson mate .....

Agent Ferguson.

Sent off a number of times and left us down to 10 men. He could just about get himself up for a game.

It's a good job we had Farrelly in that game against Coventry or we'd probably be in the National League right now.

 

[dublinbluenose]

I don’t get you sometimes Dave. You wrote Baines off as a club icon because he’s never won a trophy, yet Ferguson has won a trophy and when someone calls him a club icon you dismiss him in favour of Seamus Coleman who’s won absolutely naff all and never come close?

Bob Latchford never won anything with us.

 

[MikeH72]

Bob Latchford never won anything with us.

Neither did Baines. Dave’s criteria has always been they have to have won a trophy to be considered a club icon, that’s how he got around dismissing Baines. Now suddenly Coleman is randomly one.

 

[davek]

Of course, because an FA Cup campaign is 1 game.

Coleman hasn’t played a second in a trophy winning team either. Been here longer and played more games than Ferguson, played with better players.

1 goal he scored in that campaign - a goal when the game was already won when we beat Norwich 5-0.

Watson, Rideout, Stuart, Limpar, Jackson and Amokachi all eclipsed the Galloot in that cup run.

 

[dublinbluenose]

Neither did Baines. Dave’s criteria has always been they have to have won a trophy to be considered a club icon, that’s how he got around dismissing Baines. Now suddenly Coleman is randomly one.

I'm confused - is Ferguson a club legend because of a cup winning medal or not? Whats the criteria?

Is he more of a folk hero - such as Hibbo ?

 

[MikeH72]

1 goal he scored in that campaign - a goal when the game was already won when we beat Norwich 5-0.

Watson, Rideout, Stuart, Limpar, Jackson and Amokachi all eclipsed the Galloot in that cup run.

And? He still won a trophy and a Coleman hasn’t? I thought that’s the only way we could judge Everton legends?

 

[davek]

And? He still won a trophy and a Coleman hasn’t? I thought that’s the only way we could judge Everton legends?

It is. And he was a passenger in the cup run and therefore is as much a legend as Coleman.

 

[roydo]

It is. And he was a passenger in the cup run and therefore is as much a legend as Coleman.

Bobby Gould won an FA Cup medal as a player, and a manger. Didnt get on the pitch in either game. (I have seen his West Ham one. It was massive)

 

[davek]

Bobby Gould won an FA Cup medal as a player, and a manger. Didnt get on the pitch in either game. (I have seen his West Ham one. It was massive)

Is he considered a legend at WHU?

 

[S of S]

Agent Ferguson.

Sent off a number of times and left us down to 10 men. He could just about get himself up for a game.

It's a good job we had Farrelly in that game against Coventry or we'd probably be in the National League right now.

If you hang on a couple of years we’ll be there any way with this clown still in charge!

 

[S of S]

He played a few minutes in a cup final that was already won.

Winning 1-0 when he came on does not qualify as a game already won against one of the best teams of that era!

Do you ever read your posts before posting……?