Seamus Coleman

[Saaby]

I think hes a poor defender and average going forward. He cannot cross a ball , im actually an admirer of Darmian at United. I love a good old fashion Italian defender

 

[Tony Hibbert's 3rd leg]

Absolutely trash at defending. But he cost 60 grand and runs fast sometimes so it's all good.

 

[Dario Terracotta]

Deffo Dario. By and large he's been dreadful for 2 seasons now, he has the sporadic great performance but by and large gets found out positionally, switches off, and has been crap for far too long. Should be dropped and give Kenny, Connolly or Holgate a run.

The problem we have is our so called "senior pros" seem to get away with playing consistently crap but still get picked. Everton seems to be a too cosy club and there needs to be competition for places and there isn't.

Definitely macca, Holgate I think is a better defender and should get a run,I'm fed up to the back teeth of Seamus getting the"wrong side" of his opponent,attacking wise he offers little or nothing these days and looks like a rabbit in the headlights.

 

[maccavennie]

Definitely macca, Holgate I think is a better defender and should get a run,I'm fed up to the back teeth of Seamus getting the"wrong side" of his opponent,attacking wise he offers little or nothing these days and looks like a rabbit in the headlights.

He's been a great signing mate but I don't think ( and this is how I feel we are run ) that only because he was a bargain and played great for 3 seasons over 2 years ago that he should get a free pass. He's out of form, isn't producing the goods game in game out and should be dropped.

Like you said, there is younger kids chomping at the bit for a chance so let's give them a game and a run.

 

[ijjysmith]

He's on the list.

 

[Dario Terracotta]

He's been a great signing mate but I don't think ( and this is how I feel we are run ) that only because he was a bargain and played great for 3 seasons over 2 years ago that he should get a free pass. He's out of form, isn't producing the goods game in game out and should be dropped.

Like you said, there is younger kids chomping at the bit for a chance so let's give them a game and a run.

Deffo,probably clutching at straws but Davies offered a little bit more than nothing when he came onlolBarry is out suspended next game,please god no Cleverley,probably Swansea is the type of opponent Coleman may be suited to having a better game against getting forward,although I'd like Holgate to come inlolHopefully a couple of the kids on the bench though.

 

[DanEFC92]

Crap

 

[maccavennie]

Deffo,probably clutching at straws but Davies offered a little bit more than nothing when he came onlolBarry is out suspended next game,please god no Cleverley,probably Swansea is the type of opponent Coleman may be suited to having a better game against getting forward,although I'd like Holgate to come inlolHopefully a couple of the kids on the bench though.

Davies showed more in 15 minutes than the 11 did who started that game. For that reason alone they should be ashamed of themselves.

I would give Holgate, Davies starts and on the bench have Kenny/Connolly and Walsh of fit along with Calvert-Lewin as Valencia is basically just a waste of space.

 

[banno]

Coleman has confirmed tonight what I have suspected for a while. Not a brilliant defender at all and can only attack if he has space in front of him otherwise the ball goes backwards. Not a patch on what he was going forward and still an average defender.

 

[ToffeeTim]

Had a horrific game today. Worryingly out of form.

 

[Paul w]

Don't worry Bayern and united are after him.As if.

 

[longers]

Had a horrific game today. Worryingly out of form.

when he's been like this for 2 and a bit seasons bar the odd match you have to wonder if it's actually form related...

 

[applecrumble]

Our whole defence needs an upgrade

 

[bluestevon]

Davies showed more in 15 minutes than the 11 did who started that game. For that reason alone they should be ashamed of themselves.

I would give Holgate, Davies starts and on the bench have Kenny/Connolly and Walsh of fit along with Calvert-Lewin as Valencia is basically just a waste of space.

I think if Kenny was at a fair few other teams he'd have played by now, ignore reputations the lads got quality and desire and why not give him a go

 

[Deco]

Thought he was fantastic against West Ham but last night was horrendous.