2024/25 Sean Dyche - Sacked

Status
Not open for further replies.

Broja at 5 is generous.



I'm not saying keep Sean Dyche though.

I'm saying the problem remains that we remain relegation fodder if he leaves tomorrow.

Our inability to score goals dictates scrap.

To demonstrate that point, I'm suggesting people consider how many teams the players we rely on to create and score goals would start for.

Most don't get more than 3.
Sacking T Rex doesnt fix our problems.
 

No it doesn't. Excluding him would be cherry picking.

So go on, the number of clubs in the Prem that these start for;

Harrison
Doucoure
Mykolenko
Young
McNeil
Lindstrom
NDiaye
Calvert-Lewin
Broja
Beto

If you're finding yourself struggling to pick more than 3 for each, then maybe the players we have responsible for creating and scoring goals just aren't good enough. As they haven't been for Everton, and throughout their careers.
There is a major flaw in your argument asking how many of these players start elsewhere. This is in defence of a manager that is in my opinion under performing with these players. The point is other managers would get a better tune out of most of them and why we want him changed. Comparing Dom under Dyche to Mateta under Glasner for example makes no sense because Dom would do better under Glasner

Rinse and repeat for the others. Harrison was much better under previous managers. McNeil we don't know. Broja has had an injury plagued career. Beto did better abroad under a different style too. He is clearly not suited to hoofball.
 

No it doesn't. Excluding him would be cherry picking.

So go on, the number of clubs in the Prem that these start for;

Harrison
Doucoure
Mykolenko
Young
McNeil
Lindstrom
NDiaye
Calvert-Lewin
Broja
Beto

If you're finding yourself struggling to pick more than 3 for each, then maybe the players we have responsible for creating and scoring goals just aren't good enough. As they haven't been for Everton, and throughout their careers.

All would get moves to at least four or five clubs minimum. If a deal is right. Like any player.

Dyche wasn't leading teams before Everton to 100 plus goals per season. He's consistently delivered low scoring teams throughout his managerial career.
 
There is a major flaw in your argument asking how many of these players start elsewhere.

There isn't.

It's a very simple point

I've provided a list of players who are responsible for creating/scoring goals at the club and asked people to share how many teams in the league they'd start for.

Really simple and straight forward point.

You see, it gives an indication on the level in which the players who are sat 16th are underperforming.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top