We have the defenders we need to defend against the vast majority of teams in this league. Look what happened last season with the same set of defenders: we had the 4th tightest defensive record.
We have the personnel to play both ways, of course. But we have to pick and choose which ones we go for in an attacking sense: B'mouth at home made sense to dominate the game and attack the opposition (a game we should easily have won); Newcastle at home it didn't make sense to and we didn't and got a creditable draw.
Dyche's job is to get enough points to keep us up. He's dong that and until he isn't I dont feel inclined to get shut of him, because we all know from recent memory just how perilously close other managers took us to the brink.
Dave , you constantly spout about how crap DCL is … and I agree . And how we should be aiming for better etc and you are constantly saying things ( I’m paraphrasing here) that are inline with “ we are Everton and should better”
You are saying that last season we had the 4th best defence … which is true . Other teams have improved , our rb is now 39 and Keane is now getting game time … it’s not the same defence anymore .
Dyche was brought in to keep us in the league … well he done that in his first 6 months ….
Then again last year….
So the target is the same this year?
Shouldn’t every year be to improve ? Build? Evolve ? Change ? At least try to do any of those things?
He’s changed nothing from an attacking point of view … hasn’t developed any players to improve them.
He has just resigned all the old has beens that he picks every week and played the same team , formation and style that he has always played .
He still Relies on corners , still can’t set a team up to win within the first weeks of a season , doesn’t have the players fit for the first game , and will not drop players that are costing us points unless he is forced too.
There is no point in backing him with funds in January …. Therefore we are better off getting someone new in and giving them time to change the style, learn the squad and then back them with funds … unless you feel we won’t need to strengthen in January as we will not be in the bottom 4-5?
If that’s the case keep him… but 5 points from 7 games without having the worst fixtures in the world … is less than a point a game and has us finishing on 35 points …. You think that’s good enough ?
If not… then make the call now and change it