Absolutely ridiculous to be asking this question, and even more to be even considering responding 'yes'!
Despite any misgivings I have about Martinez's approach this season (see below) it is the players, more than the manager, that have themselves to look at here. They have been putting in disjointed performances all season long. Some of this can be absolved due to the huge tactics shake-up after the first few games and the fact our style of football has gone from attractive to absolute crap. Our attacking, passing game is absolutely non-existent. Even the reporter on Sky Sports News today was exasperated at how 8 minutes into injury time, we were knocking the ball around without seemingly any idea of what to do with it. I think this sums up our season this far.
Some of the 'interest' shown by the players out there lately harks back to the Walter Smith days. Not a pleasant thought.
As I said, I am not absolving Martinez entirely. His bizarre selections like Hibbert at left-back and questionable dealings in the transfer market have done him no favours. Although I think he can be excused with Lukaku, as based on his performances last year and his goals, any manager would have fought to sign him. But he is now looking uninterested and some of Mourinho's criticisms of him (or should I say 'warnings') seem to ringing very true right now.
I know Coleman has been injured for many parts of the season but when he has been fit, it is quite noticeable there has been a huge reduction in his marauding runs down the right wing. Likewise with Baines on the left. Has this been sacrificed to 'shore up' at the back? If it has, then it is not working. We continue to have the same defensive problems, now with less attacking threat!
An interesting parallel, after a poor performance by the Republic of Ireland national team a few months back, the tv panel in the studio were bemoaning how Martin O'Neill appears to curb Coleman's attacking flair. They praised Martinez and how he let Seamus express himself and his attacking side. This was based on last season and some earlier performances this season. It appears now that Martinez has got him playing the O'Neill way.
Why is this then?
Martinez has always got his teams to play attractive, passing football. Even if it cost them at the back, and he never backed down on this. The fact that we appear to have abandoned this now, is perplexing. The early season debacle is over now.
Is it that the players we have simply aren't capable? Has Martinez has changed his style of game of his own accord? Or have other influences on the club have leaned on Martinez to 'adapt' his style of play, in order to gain results over style. The results haven't been forthcoming since the adoption of the less attacking style either way!
As for McGeady, I doubt for one second he would have made any difference today. He has been part of some of our other pitiful performances this year. His occasional good delivery is far outweighed by his senseless dribbling, poor passing and resulting loss of possession.