Steven Naismith

Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree that his technical ability doesn't always match his intelligence on a football field, he's a good team player though and brings something a bit different when required. I'd keep hold of him

I'd say his lack of technical ability is a major hindrance to our fluid, attacking style of play, hence why we mostly struggle to create any chances when he's on the pitch. The odd freak game aside, it affects us massively. The proof was last season, when he started most games and we were appalling.

As a side note, he has barely been seen in the last month and we've been banging goals in left right and centre. Only our shocking defence has prevented us from being higher in the table
 

The only way we can let him go in January is if we have a replacement lined up, same as Mirallas. They are both first team squad players and we can't afford to let them go without replacing.

If either of them go and no one comes in we have Lukaku and Kone as our only two forwards, and just Geri as the only decent out and out winger. A couple of injuries there and we're screwed.

The likes of Pienaar, McGeady and even Gibson to a certain extent (with Besic, McCarthy, Barry, Osman and Cleverley as CM) can go in January without needing an immediate replacement, although obviously in the summer it would need to be addressed.
 
I'd say his lack of technical ability is a major hindrance to our fluid, attacking style of play, hence why we mostly struggle to create any chances when he's on the pitch. The odd freak game aside, it affects us massively. The proof was last season, when he started most games and we were appalling.

As a side note, he has barely been seen in the last month and we've been banging goals in left right and centre. Only our shocking defence has prevented us from being higher in the table

The fact that he played so much last season showed how stretched the squad was. Naismith was playing almost every minute of every game in the first half of the season. This season we have a fresh Naismith, Mirallas etc to call upon when needed. Naismith had a positive impact towards the end of Martinez' first season when he hadn't been used much before that. He could have the same impact this season if we keep him
 
he's not essential but an alright option to throw on now and then. Main thing is he seems like a genuinely decent bloke, if he wants more game time let him go. Could see him doing a job at say a Sunderland picking up on scraps and broken play in a more direct team, think our styles a bit above his skill set.
 

If we get a bid of £8m i'd rip their arm off. Decent player, great bloke, honest tryer but probably not good enough for where we want to get to. I'd wish him well wherever he ends up, hope he does us a few favours scoring against our rivals for a european spot.
 
We couldn't let Naismith go unless we had a good replacement for him. He may not be the best but he still gets playing time unlike completely crap players like McGeady.
 
Interesting interview from Martinez, almost inviting bids for him in January

http://www.theguardian.com/football/2015/dec/10/everton-steven-naismith-roberto-martinez

Everton will not stand in Steven Naismith’s way, says Roberto Martínez
• Norwich had £8m for the Scot rejected in late August
• We will try to help him out, adds Blues manager Martínez


Everton's Steven Naismith, an almost perpetual substitute, limbers up at half-time of the Manchester United game back in April. Photograph: Carl Recine/Action Images via Reuters
Paul Wilson
Roberto Martínez will not stand in Steven Naismith’s way if the frustrated striker receives an offer of more regular football during next month’s transfer window. Norwich City, Everton’s opponents on Saturday, made a late bid for the Scot at the end of the summer window, one that Everton were not minded to consider, but Martínez promised the player that the situation could be reassessed.

“The offer from Norwich arrived very late and I wouldn’t have had time to replace him,” the Everton manager said. “I was honest with the player and told him he was too important to the club to be allowed to leave. I didn’t know at that stage how Arouna Koné was going to be, or how Gerard Deulofeu was going to settle in, but I had a good idea that Steven still had plenty to contribute, and so it has proved. He has been a consistent performer since I came to this club, but at 29 I can fully understand him wanting to go somewhere else if he thinks he can be the main player.”

Naismith has been effective this season, most notably when scoring a hat-trick after coming on as a substitute against Chelsea, though with Romelu Lukaku an ever-present for Everton and Koné and Deulofeu fitting in alongside the main striker, the former Rangers player has found his starting opportunities limited.

“I respect Steven as a player and a professional,” Martínez said. “He gives everything to the cause and if he says something you have to listen. I do not want to lose him but I understand his position. I think if Naisy was 22 years old he would be happy to fight for his place – you have that confidence at that age – but when you are 29 and not playing as often as you would like it is completely different. I will talk to Steven in January and see where we are. If he feels we can offer him something he will enjoy over the next six months then fine; if not we will try to help him out.”

Martínez advises players to be careful what they wish for – “Pedro at Barcelona wanted to leave all the time, now he is on the bench at Chelsea” – though recognises that individual cases are always different. “I am not here to keep everyone happy, I am here to keep a level of consistency on the pitch and to provide clarity so that every player knows what his role is,” he explained. “Some players who say they need to move on because they are not playing enough games really mean that they know the players getting picked ahead of them are better.

“Some have more personal reasons. Kevin Mirallas, for instance, needs to think about how not playing for Everton might affect his selection for the Euros next summer. You have to try and help someone in that situation, if he needs to be playing. We have helped players in the past. Nikica Jelavic had it in his head that he wanted to play against Brazil in the last World Cup. You can’t really deny a player an ambition like that.

“Brazil had Croatia first up and Mario Mandzukic was suspended. We let him go in January and he started against Brazil in the summer. We had a fantastic deal of £6.5m [with Hull]. It all made sense. It was the same with Johnny Heitinga. Louis van Gaal told him he would not be considered if he was not playing for a club, so we allowed him to go to Fulham. He wasn’t playing with us and it was only fair.”

The defender Brendan Galloway has signed a new contract until June 2020. The 19-year-old full-back was given his chance in the first team at the end of last season after injuries to Leighton Baines and Bryan Oviedo and has made 16 appearances in this campaign.
 

He's a great lad and fine ambassador for our club - and he's even put in some great performances at times - but he's clearly down the pecking order and deserves to be allowed to move on.

Some players have earnt the gratitude.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top