Don't worry mate, whoever they pick I don't think it will be to please meTo me the captain isn't made to appease the fans it is made to set forward who you want the leader of the club to be. For me that means obviously the person should be a leader in the squad but also should be someone who is playing at the standard we want. That leaves Digne and Keane since Seamus is probably not going to be an automatic starter much longer and even if he is doesn't hit the level of someone like Digne.
Now if Seamus is the clear leader of the team and no one steps up to that level it will have to be him. But I still don't think who the supporters see as their representative should matter at all.