Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

The Everton Board Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Moshiri needs to come out and say that the current board is being replaced. Our best hope for the future is a purposeful structure with competent people filling key roles, like Brighton, Brentford and Newcastle have done.
Never gonna happen whilst Moshiri is here. He’s clueless and takes advice from the wrong people
 

You could see it like that, perhaps fairly to an extent. Or, you could see that he was promoting a manager that would fit the profile he had envisaged/sold.

That being a young, progressive manager who would fit the mould (play our way) who would have players who were young, could develop and sell on value.

Carlo is a great manager and person I was happy we appointed, but objectively you can't say he was the first, did the second or facilitated the latter.

We played a certain way he wanted and brought in expensive, older players who we could not move on for a profit, which is the exact opposite of the model.

Rafael was even further away from it, so if he's meant to be a DoF and fulfil his remit should he have gone, 'Yes, let's appoint Carlo and go against all our plans?'

Look how PSV, Brighton, Dortmund and so many others operate - that's what he'll have envisaged. Then, look where we are and the situation we're in.

We were in the bottom 5 and Artetas arsenal started really slowly. Its easy to say now "well I actually wanted Arteta" but he has previously briefed the athletic that he wanted Potter. Now Potter isn't flavour of the month he's saying it's Arteta so I wish he'd make his mind up.

His 'model' also just didn't exist. If you exclude Richarlison who we would all agree was a Silva signing we only had Digne and Kean - by some miracle - we broke even on and Nkounkou we will have made profit on from his signings. Branthwaite might one day but he hasn't been sold yet. Doucoure, Gomes, Gbamin, Delph, Mina, Bernard all on massive wages will have left for nothing from a combined 110 million transfers. That isn't how Brighton, Dortmund and Co. operate.

He was fine with Iwobi being signed from the powers that be, Ancelotti getting appointed and even didn't resign when Benitez was appointed. He then 'resigned' when people started rightfully pointing out he had signed a bunch of dossers on massive wages.

The board are still to blame because he was laughably appointed to it and so in effect had to review his own performance on whether he should be sacked or not.
 

We were in the bottom 5 and Artetas arsenal started really slowly. Its easy to say now "well I actually wanted Arteta" but he has previously briefed the athletic that he wanted Potter. Now Potter isn't flavour of the month he's saying it's Arteta so I wish he'd make his mind up.

His 'model' also just didn't exist. If you exclude Richarlison who we would all agree was a Silva signing we only had Digne and Kean - by some miracle - we broke even on and Nkounkou we will have made profit on from his signings. Branthwaite might one day but he hasn't been sold yet. Doucoure, Gomes, Gbamin, Delph, Mina, Bernard all on massive wages will have left for nothing from a combined 110 million transfers. That isn't how Brighton, Dortmund and Co. operate.

He was fine with Iwobi being signed from the powers that be, Ancelotti getting appointed and even didn't resign when Benitez was appointed. He then 'resigned' when people started rightfully pointing out he had signed a bunch of dossers on massive wages.

The board are still to blame because he was laughably appointed to it and so in effect had to review his own performance on whether he should be sacked or not.
Mina was twenty-three when we signed him as was Gbamin. Arguably, they were still young players with potential on the pitch and sell on value.

Gomes was older at twenty-five, I'll give you that, but still at the time a good five or more years left at his prime would have been the mindset. Godrey too.

Doucouré was wanted by Ancelotti and Delph, well Delph was a faux pas. The thing I also find questionable is the 'fine' bit with certain signing - was he?

Would he have wanted Allan, Rodriguez et al.? No. Did he want Rafael? No. The point being that ultimately his wishes weren't listened to on many occasions.

He did what those above him asked rather than fulfil the model, which is the problem. You may wish he'd taken the moral stance of walking away...

... but would you walk away from a well paid job? Brands wasn't perfect, but the flak he gets is laughable. He's the fall guy for the board or their apologists.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top