Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

The NFL Thread, 2019

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's attempted assault with a weapon. Even if you went to swing and miss doesn't mean you don't accidentally catch someone if they are moving towards the path, not realising that you are about to swing a helmet. You can have a bit of pushing and even fisticuffs but that was one step beyond. If you don't stamp on these things then your saying it's acceptable as you'll only get a x game ban.

I’m no lawyer but I’d it assault if there is a struggle between two people on equal terms? It’s not like he left a bar an came back with a knife or gun. Rudolph instigated, Garrett responded, Rudolph provoked/responded again (nut punch or not), then Garrett responded again (over the top). Seems like it’s not assault or attempted murder like some say.
 
You dont have to ban people for a year to say something is against the rules, it's hardly even a fight

It looks bad for the sport, come down hard once and the players might think a year's salary is a bit much before kicking off. Like I say, got no issue with some needle maybe even a punch but you don't take off someone's protection and try and bludgeon them with it. This kid needs to go play Ice Hockey instead.
 
giphy.gif
 
It looks bad for the sport, come down hard once and the players might think a year's salary is a bit much before kicking off. Like I say, got no issue with some needle maybe even a punch but you don't take off someone's protection and try and bludgeon them with it. This kid needs to go play Ice Hockey instead.
They both grabbed each others helmet and wrestled, it's absolutely nothing and the hyperbolic overreaction will just drive players into their shells. Give him a whatever game ban for violent conduct and stop acting like he assassinated Kennedy
 


He wasn't playing that well when all this started. Certainly not on the levels he had been at the year or so before.
I'm sure he's still ok like, but he's been out a long time to just walk into a team and pick it up immediately.
 


He wasn't playing that well when all this started. Certainly not on the levels he had been at the year or so before.
I'm sure he's still ok like, but he's been out a long time to just walk into a team and pick it up immediately.

Oh, he'd been playing absolutely shockingly.

But, it's not like teams have picked up far better QBs and given them a shot over him. It's ridiculous.

He should have been on a team - or bouncing from a few teams – regardless. He's better than ya Luke Faulk's and Jeff Driskel's.
 
Ok I’ve done some googling and I’m doubled down on the “this is not assault” stance. This is clearly “provocation”, and I rest my case, your honor.

Say you get in a fight with your neighbor and you had a tool belt on. It's an even struggle just pushing and shoving, then the neighbor rips the hammer out your belt and attempts to hit you in the head with it and grazes you. It's the exact samething.

It's not provocation. You have no evidence of provocation.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top