It's attempted assault with a weapon. Even if you went to swing and miss doesn't mean you don't accidentally catch someone if they are moving towards the path, not realising that you are about to swing a helmet. You can have a bit of pushing and even fisticuffs but that was one step beyond. If you don't stamp on these things then your saying it's acceptable as you'll only get a x game ban.
I’m no lawyer but I’d it assault if there is a struggle between two people on equal terms? It’s not like he left a bar an came back with a knife or gun. Rudolph instigated, Garrett responded, Rudolph provoked/responded again (nut punch or not), then Garrett responded again (over the top). Seems like it’s not assault or attempted murder like some say.