The summer 2013 Everton transfer rumourZ thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

ijjysmith said:
Hmmmm not sure on either of those.

That position is certainly not a priority for me either.

He doesn't offer value for money. It's a no from me.
Click to expand...

He fitter, he can run all day, he younger, he good enough for this league, he is a good passer, he can defend and attack. But I do agree that he will be overprice and will not give us value. I would pay up to 8 million for him which wouldn't be enough. He only cost Wigan 1.2 million so it a good sign that Martinez can finds cheap gems.
 
Jags..class said:
He fitter, he can run all day, he younger, he good enough for this league, he is a good passer, he can defend and attack. But I do agree that he will be overprice and will not give us value. I would pay up to 8 million for him which wouldn't be enough. He only cost Wigan 1.2 million so it a good sign that Martinez can finds cheap gems.
Click to expand...

Can you tell me what you thought of him during Wigan's 3-0 loss to Newcastle this season?

Or in their 3-2 loss to Swansea. In particular his part in their 3rd goal.
 

Jags..class said:
He fitter, he can run all day, he younger, he good enough for this league, he is a good passer, he can defend and attack. But I do agree that he will be overprice and will not give us value. I would pay up to 8 million for him which wouldn't be enough. He only cost Wigan 1.2 million so it a good sign that Martinez can finds cheap gems.
Click to expand...

For me McCarthy is vastly overrated here. I think he's ok with potential to improve. If we want to keep our top 6/7 statue, we shouldn't be looking to sign someone like him because he won't improve our starting 11 (I think Osman is better than him; overall ability).
 
ijjysmith said:
Can you tell me what you thought of him during Wigan's 3-0 loss to Newcastle this season?

Or in their 3-2 loss to Swansea. In particular his part in their 3rd goal.
Click to expand...

Cant remember the mistake but all players make mistakes, I do remember his run for the goal which was good, but he not a defender so its not really his job to clear the line. He is an under-rated player and will improve in a much better team. Didn't see the Newcastle game.
 
Jags..class said:
Cant remember the mistake but all players make mistakes, I do remember his run for the goal which was good, but he not a defender so its not really his job to clear the line. He is an under-rated player and will improve in a much better team. Didn't see the Newcastle game.
Click to expand...

For me we could and hopefully will get much better players than him in.

Edit...

And hang on. Because he's not a defender he can't be at fault for a goal?
 
He's going to Napoli when they sell Cavani, and its also going to be at least double £7m. Cant believe he got paid to write that ****e.
 

ijjysmith said:
For me we could and hopefully will get much better players than him in.

Edit...

And hang on. Because he's not a defender he can't be at fault for a goal?
Click to expand...

Every player is at fault for a goal at some point. Unless he's doing it all the time I don't think you can really hold it against him.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top