Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Transfer Rumour Theo Walcott

Would you like him?

  • Yes

    Votes: 690 66.2%
  • No

    Votes: 241 23.1%
  • Cheese on toast

    Votes: 112 10.7%

  • Total voters
    1,043
Status
Not open for further replies.
I had considered who he was playing for Orly. Even in that 7 year period for Arsenal he would have finished top scorer once, second highest twice and third highest on another occasion. The other years he only played a handful of games due to injury but still managed to finish 5th highest scorer at worst.

My point, and I probably didn't make it very clearly, is that he isn't and has never been (apart from a very occasional match) their primary focus of attack, and won't be with us either. He's either played as a winger or wide in a 433, and his goal/assist record, even in an attacking free flowing side like Arsenal, is none too shabby for somebody playing in that position. He's been in competition with players like Sanchez, Giroud, Wellbeck, Ozil, Cazorla, Ramsey, Nasri, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Wilshire and Van Persie during that period, so game time has been hard to come by.

I'm assuming that you are against the signing mate. I can understand why and have many concerns myself. But, if I'm honest, I've seen us buy a lot worse over the last 3/4 years. Compare it to Oxlade-Chamberlain who the RS paid well over £30m for. He has 9 premier goals compared to Walcott's 65.


No not against the Walcott signing at all. I think it is a bit of shame that we are going after players like him, but that's where we are currently. I don't see how we get a similar league-ready player for anything like that kind of money in January. Plus if you are buying Walcott 6 months before the WC is easily the best time to sign him.

I just think he isn't that good a player, and his goal scoring record is pretty poor for someone to have played at Arsenal for the last ten years.
 
I mean it is actually a fact that attacking players peak at 25 and they decline rapidly at around 29-30.

There is plenty of research on it. Of course there are exceptions, but they tend to be players who adapt their game, like Ronaldo.

http://www.espn.co.uk/football/blog...goalkeepers-and-central-defenders-peak-latest
Just look at the list of players who are 30 or over, are playing in attacking positions and have made an appearance in the Premier League this season. It's very short on quality and numbers. The only players in the top 6 sides are Ibrahimovic, Giroud, Pedro and Llorente. Of them Pedro has regularly started games. The rest of the list doesn't make great reading with the exception of Vardy: Crouch, Defoe, Murray, Walters, Routledge, Okazaki, Rooney, Ulloa, Vardy, Long, Pugh, Lennon, Hemed, Amrabat, Mirallas, Dyer, Diouf and that is the full list.
 
I don't want to put a downer on things before the lads even kicked a ball for us, but anybody looking at this signing cos of his goal ratio at arsenal needs to seriously think again or they are gonna be very disappointed. We don't play like arsenal, we don't create chances like arsenal + we now have big Sam at the helm! It's prob more realistic looking at his goal return for England. I certainly ain't jumping with joy on this signing but will give the lad a chance as any new signing, but don't hurt yourselves even more by believing that goal ratio will follow him here!
 

Loan of 32 year old player in a position we desperately needed vs £20m on a player with questionable drive and a patchy goal scoring record.

Ah yes, absolutely comparable :hayee::hayee::hayee::hayee::hayee:
Patchy goal scoring record? You mean more goals than any player has scored for Everton in the premier league era? :hayee::hayee::hayee::hayee::hayee:
 
Take your pace
Take your goal scoring
Take your assists
And take your brilliant footballing brain OUT OF HEAR!!!

1371562825_955967453.gif
 

Patchy goal scoring record? You mean more goals than any player has scored for Everton in the premier league era? :hayee::hayee::hayee::hayee::hayee:

Do let me know a striker that has played for us for ten seasons in the premier league please mate in the same period as Walcott played for Arsenal :hayee::hayee::hayee::hayee:

Look, it'll be the same old thing. The same people who were memeing away about Sizeable Samuel, and were slating Wayne Rooney, and telling us Klaassen had an amazing footy brain, are all doing the whole "can't believe our fans are turning up their nose at Walcott we're so bad".

*shrug* pretty easy pattern emerging.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to put a downer on things before the lads even kicked a ball for us, but anybody looking at this signing cos of his goal ratio at arsenal needs to seriously think again or they are gonna be very disappointed. We don't play like arsenal, we don't create chances like arsenal + we now have big Sam at the helm! It's prob more realistic looking at his goal return for England. I certainly ain't jumping with joy on this signing but will give the lad a chance as any new signing, but don't hurt yourselves even more by believing that goal ratio will follow him here!

Well fortunately only half of that productivity will still be better than anything we've had from a wide player in the last generation.
 
Yeah but resale value. I thought the whole point in signing someone was based on how much you can sell them for in a few years time?

You nearly had me then, very nearly.

I was just about to bite back with " the whole point of buying players is to make you into a better team, one capable of challenging for honours ", then realised you were speaking with your tongue firmly placed in your cheek.

I hope. ;)
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top