• Participation within this subforum is only available to members who have had 5+ posts approved elsewhere.

Today’s Football 2020/21 Season

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're entitled to your opinion but the most favourable verdict to the officials I've heard is someone describe it as very soft

He falls to the ground, knees tucked in. He finishes with them outstretched in an opponents midriff. He has no reason to stretch his legs with PVA stood over him. You just can’t do it in the modern game whether it’s soft or not it’s just a black & white rule.

 


He falls to the ground, knees tucked in. He finishes with them outstretched in an opponents midriff. He has no reason to stretch his legs with PVA stood over him. You just can’t do it in the modern game whether it’s soft or not it’s just a black & white rule.


Why are you including a still photo - they can always be misleading, I've seen it dozens of times, and dispute your description but there's little point in continuing this so I won't.
 
He falls to the ground, knees tucked in. He finishes with them outstretched in an opponents midriff. He has no reason to stretch his legs with PVA stood over him. You just can’t do it in the modern game whether it’s soft or not it’s just a black & white rule.



Agree 100% - but there will still be some who will dispute it...
 
Why are you including s still photo, I've seen it dozens of times, and dispute your description but there's little point in continuing this so I won't.

You dispute his legs go from tucked in to stretched straight with PVA stood over him? Then you’re in the minority. I thought a still might help you see that’s a red in football.
 

Why are you including a still photo - they can always be misleading, I've seen it dozens of times, and dispute your description but there's little point in continuing this so I won't.
1. Because it shows what happened; and
2. That is a most unnatural position to try to get yourself up from the ground. Particularly with an opponent next to you that close.

Or are you seeing something totally different and innocuous...?
 
I agree mate and the still photo is completely deceiving. I re - watched and still think that's a very soft red

There aren’t any soft reds when it comes to things like that in modern football.

- There are no soft kick outs - it’s a red.
- There are no soft headbutt/motioning with the head - it’s a red.
- There are no legal tackles from behind even if you win the ball - it’s a foul.

It might suck, it might grate on the older generation but it’s just the rule now.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top